So far I've come across the OEM and Sherman versions and a generic version on rockauto.com.

Does anyone know what the differences are between them? I called Sherman and they said they didn't have a picture available but they did say that theirs might not come with an emblem.

 

OEM is the way to go, will fit perfectly with no gaps. you can find oem for pretty cheep online, i picked up brand new on here for $50 shipped