Knock in 2nd gear pull
Your ECU pulling 2-3 deg in certain areas running 20+ PSI on Cali 91 octane (almost comparable to east coast 89) is not alarming. You can tune around it regardless. Is the ROM otherwise stock? If so, you could also be seeing "rich knock" which occurs when the AFRs are excessively rich.
Last edited by A418t81; Dec 27, 2006 at 07:51 AM.
Well, I never really said anything about solving my problem, I'm only simply letting you guys know what happened. Yes I can go and retard my timing and I can also not put my foot all the way down on the go pedal as well. I just think its a little disheartening to see this happen on a pretty much stock car.
Well, I never really said anything about solving my problem, I'm only simply letting you guys know what happened. Yes I can go and retard my timing and I can also not put my foot all the way down on the go pedal as well. I just think its a little disheartening to see this happen on a pretty much stock car.
that your car is designed for at least 93 octane.
Also have you logged since using 76 ?
Well, I never really said anything about solving my problem, I'm only simply letting you guys know what happened. Yes I can go and retard my timing and I can also not put my foot all the way down on the go pedal as well. I just think its a little disheartening to see this happen on a pretty much stock car.
Yes I've logged it since using 76 (my updates are on my first post). I think now I'm either going to:
1. Not going to drive it hard or at least not very often
2. Mix in some 100 oct or some other race fuel and then beat on it
3. Look into using some other octane booster like toluene
4. Retune my stock rom (retard timing)
If only we had 93 here, I wouldn't even think twice about using it...
Yes I've logged it since using 76 (my updates are on my first post). I think now I'm either going to:
1. Not going to drive it hard or at least not very often
2. Mix in some 100 oct or some other race fuel and then beat on it
3. Look into using some other octane booster like toluene
4. Retune my stock rom (retard timing)

Yes I've logged it since using 76 (my updates are on my first post). I think now I'm either going to:
1. Not going to drive it hard or at least not very often
2. Mix in some 100 oct or some other race fuel and then beat on it
3. Look into using some other octane booster like toluene
4. Retune my stock rom (retard timing)

Since I only drive the Evo for leisure, it gets a steady diet of 100 octane.

At least you have a nice IX MR... That's a good reason to be happy.
Have you leaned the A/F out at all yet? I havent seen a 02 voltage chart, but if you are on stock ignition I am wondering if most of the rest of your map is still stock as well? Adding exhaust components will only compound the issue and cause the possibility of rich knock becuase of overfueling. Stock fuel map and TBE resulted in 9.5:1 AFR on my MR. I know its been mentioned but since you didnt comment on it I wanted to bring it up again. A stock ignition map shouldnt knock, period. It is well retarded (i.e. ZERO advance numbers) at peak torque.
EDIT- Also your high rpm knock is at normal advance numbers, I think its probably a result of the lean spool function screwing with your AFR's there. I had a similar issue until I completely disabled it. The fact that you have no knock at peak torque with 0*, and 2 counts with 6* advance leads me to believe its probably more a combination of fuel and spark than specifically one or the other.
EDIT- Also your high rpm knock is at normal advance numbers, I think its probably a result of the lean spool function screwing with your AFR's there. I had a similar issue until I completely disabled it. The fact that you have no knock at peak torque with 0*, and 2 counts with 6* advance leads me to believe its probably more a combination of fuel and spark than specifically one or the other.
Last edited by JohnBradley; Dec 27, 2006 at 09:38 AM. Reason: reviewed another log
Have you leaned the A/F out at all yet? I havent seen a 02 voltage chart, but if you are on stock ignition I am wondering if most of the rest of your map is still stock as well? Adding exhaust components will only compound the issue and cause the possibility of rich knock becuase of overfueling. Stock fuel map and TBE resulted in 9.5:1 AFR on my MR. I know its been mentioned but since you didnt comment on it I wanted to bring it up again. A stock ignition map shouldnt knock, period. It is well retarded (i.e. ZERO advance numbers) at peak torque.
EDIT- Also your high rpm knock is at normal advance numbers, I think its probably a result of the lean spool function screwing with your AFR's there. I had a similar issue until I completely disabled it. The fact that you have no knock at peak torque with 0*, and 2 counts with 6* advance leads me to believe its probably more a combination of fuel and spark than specifically one or the other.
EDIT- Also your high rpm knock is at normal advance numbers, I think its probably a result of the lean spool function screwing with your AFR's there. I had a similar issue until I completely disabled it. The fact that you have no knock at peak torque with 0*, and 2 counts with 6* advance leads me to believe its probably more a combination of fuel and spark than specifically one or the other.
OK, so I decided to throw in some 100oct from a local 76 pump. I had about 1/3 tank of 91oct and I mixed it with ~1.8 gal of 100oct so I was somewhere within 95-96 octane at least after mixing. Anyways, I'm happy to say that the 2nd to 3rd gear pulls were pretty much knock free which means the culprit is the crappy 91 octane gas we get. The timing was not pulled during the runs. This to me is very alarming since my car is pretty much stock AND I'm on the stock ECU tune. That means cars that run on 91 octane could be knocking like crazy especially in 2nd gear.
That is why I keep telling people to STOP USING 91 octane and start mixing to get the desired 93-94 octane. I used to get those NASTY AFR spikes indicating a misfire when I ran 91 octane gas. Once I switched to mixing, all these spikes disappeared. Recently, I logged an Evo 8 that used 91 octane and it had the same spikes that I used to have.
The Evo is NOT like every other turbo car. It is a VERY high boost turbo car. This car needs a steady diet of high octane gas.
If only we had 93 here, I wouldn't even think twice about using it...
Yes I've logged it since using 76 (my updates are on my first post). I think now I'm either going to:
1. Not going to drive it hard or at least not very often
2. Mix in some 100 oct or some other race fuel and then beat on it
3. Look into using some other octane booster like toluene
4. Retune my stock rom (retard timing)

Yes I've logged it since using 76 (my updates are on my first post). I think now I'm either going to:
1. Not going to drive it hard or at least not very often
2. Mix in some 100 oct or some other race fuel and then beat on it
3. Look into using some other octane booster like toluene
4. Retune my stock rom (retard timing)

....You may want to think about that...I see you are in Sacramento (probably 2 hrs. from Vishnu Tuning) -- I believe Shiv is converting some folks to E85 if you are interested.
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post










