How I Fixed my flutter / sputter at low boost
#31
Evolved Member
iTrader: (1)
That is unlike any flutter I've ever heard. I highly doubt it is something normal. It sounds as if pressure is never applied to the other side of the BOV keeping it open...but for some reason my browser can't see video only audio...
Edit: I was just looking at your pictures. Source the MBC air supply from a different place than your BOV. When air is bled out to your wastegate from that line by your MBC, it creates a pressure differential between the top and bottom of the BOV letting it open. Basically you are having the opposite of compressor surge. Your BOV is opening too easily as opposed to not easily enough. This is why lowering the boost to close to the pressure threshold of the WGA spring helps get rid of this problem. When the system is closed such that no air is making it to the WGA, your BOV is equalized. However, the more pressure that builds, the more the valve tries to hold the wastegate open, the more air is bled away from your BOV, and the less pressure it has holding the valve closed. Then when the wastegate opens, less pressure is made by the turbo, so less pressure is pushing the BOV open, so then the air can start going to your engine again, which makes more boost, repeat repeat etc. However, as boost comes on even harder, the manifold pressure is high enough to supply that little line with enough pressure to hold your WGA open and keep the BOV pressurized, not to mention the WGA pressure is not fluctuating as much as it was during transient boost levels, and is now holding steady, so there is less need to vent air back through the MBC while opening-closing-opening the wastegate. Remember at part throttle the throttle body butterfly is slightly closed so as the engine revs there is likely to be fluctuations in the pressure differential of the air on either side of it.
Hope that helps!
Edit #2: If what I said above isn't obvious, here is what I recommend you do:
Edit: I was just looking at your pictures. Source the MBC air supply from a different place than your BOV. When air is bled out to your wastegate from that line by your MBC, it creates a pressure differential between the top and bottom of the BOV letting it open. Basically you are having the opposite of compressor surge. Your BOV is opening too easily as opposed to not easily enough. This is why lowering the boost to close to the pressure threshold of the WGA spring helps get rid of this problem. When the system is closed such that no air is making it to the WGA, your BOV is equalized. However, the more pressure that builds, the more the valve tries to hold the wastegate open, the more air is bled away from your BOV, and the less pressure it has holding the valve closed. Then when the wastegate opens, less pressure is made by the turbo, so less pressure is pushing the BOV open, so then the air can start going to your engine again, which makes more boost, repeat repeat etc. However, as boost comes on even harder, the manifold pressure is high enough to supply that little line with enough pressure to hold your WGA open and keep the BOV pressurized, not to mention the WGA pressure is not fluctuating as much as it was during transient boost levels, and is now holding steady, so there is less need to vent air back through the MBC while opening-closing-opening the wastegate. Remember at part throttle the throttle body butterfly is slightly closed so as the engine revs there is likely to be fluctuations in the pressure differential of the air on either side of it.
Hope that helps!
Edit #2: If what I said above isn't obvious, here is what I recommend you do:
- Run a dedicated line from the Intake Manifold to your BOV with no T.
- Run a line T'd off of another line running off the intake manifold to your MBC, or drill a nipple into your lower intercooler pipe and use that air supply.
- Problem solved.
Last edited by machron1; Jun 13, 2006 at 01:09 AM.
#33
Newbie
iTrader: (5)
Join Date: May 2005
Location: Champaign IL
Posts: 92
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Hi, drewblueeye, not trying to hijack your thread. But I'm experiencing similar problem with my bov as well. Whenever I go WOT with my GFB bov, it would go off with three chew chew chew sound. It's not the regular partial throttle fluttering, it's a distinct sound. It has never happened before until recently. Sounds like my bov is leaking or something, or maybe I have a boost leak and it's causing the bov to go off earlier? I'm not too sure what's going on, I just need some help thanks. Once again, drewblueeye, I'm not trying to hijack your thread, I'm just really desperate and need some hlep as well.
#34
Evolving Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Jul 2005
Location: Sioux CIty, IA
Posts: 352
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
WEVO,
Has this problem just started? or has it always been this way since you installed the BOV? Have you tried a different spring? I dont know about your BOV but mine came with 4 different ones... yellow, green, blue and red. the yellow is the weakest and that is what i run. Mine does a three spurt too IF i am letting off the gas really slow, but i mean really slow. BUT See my flutter problem that i am having at low boost happens with any spring that i have in.
Has this problem just started? or has it always been this way since you installed the BOV? Have you tried a different spring? I dont know about your BOV but mine came with 4 different ones... yellow, green, blue and red. the yellow is the weakest and that is what i run. Mine does a three spurt too IF i am letting off the gas really slow, but i mean really slow. BUT See my flutter problem that i am having at low boost happens with any spring that i have in.
#35
Evolved Member
iTrader: (24)
Originally Posted by drewblueeye
WEVO,
Has this problem just started? or has it always been this way since you installed the BOV? Have you tried a different spring? I dont know about your BOV but mine came with 4 different ones... yellow, green, blue and red. the yellow is the weakest and that is what i run. Mine does a three spurt too IF i am letting off the gas really slow, but i mean really slow. BUT See my flutter problem that i am having at low boost happens with any spring that i have in.
Has this problem just started? or has it always been this way since you installed the BOV? Have you tried a different spring? I dont know about your BOV but mine came with 4 different ones... yellow, green, blue and red. the yellow is the weakest and that is what i run. Mine does a three spurt too IF i am letting off the gas really slow, but i mean really slow. BUT See my flutter problem that i am having at low boost happens with any spring that i have in.
#37
Evolving Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Jul 2005
Location: Sioux CIty, IA
Posts: 352
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
yeah i had a nipple installed on my lower intercooler pipe and guess what! the flutter is gone. weird... but i called Forge Motorsport and they told me the same thing you did Machron1. All i got to say is thanks for your help Machron1, i appreciate people that answer questions and help when they can.
#38
Evolved Member
iTrader: (1)
Originally Posted by drewblueeye
yeah i had a nipple installed on my lower intercooler pipe and guess what! the flutter is gone. weird... but i called Forge Motorsport and they told me the same thing you did Machron1. All i got to say is thanks for your help Machron1, i appreciate people that answer questions and help when they can.
#41
Evolving Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Jul 2005
Location: Sioux CIty, IA
Posts: 352
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
i took the BR lower intercooler pipe and the factory lower intercooler pipe into a welding shop had them cut off the nipple from the factory pipe and weld it on the BR pipe in the same place, it cost me $10.00. but if you are a real DIY kind of guy, i guess you could go to a BIG hardware store like Menards or lowes and go to the plumbing section and try and find a smaller nipple and some rubber washers and drill the hole yourself. I wouldnt trust it not to leak that is why i had mine welded.
#43
Evolved Member
iTrader: (1)
Originally Posted by 20psiMR
Good ole quality buscher products!
#44
Evolved Member
iTrader: (44)
Join Date: Oct 2003
Location: Charleston, WV
Posts: 4,409
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Just for the record their exhaust do have flanges now... you can even get the quick release vband type clamps Granted their stuff isn't the best looking stuff on the market.. but it's light.. performs and won't cost you an arm/leg.
#45
Evolved Member
iTrader: (1)
Originally Posted by justchil
Just for the record their exhaust do have flanges now... you can even get the quick release vband type clamps Granted their stuff isn't the best looking stuff on the market.. but it's light.. performs and won't cost you an arm/leg.