Testing Effect of High Flow cat vs test pipe on Stage IV Evo IX
I think the testpipe makes the car sound good at wot but for everyday driving it makes the car sound too hollowed out at low speeds and not very good. I had my test pipe on for 2 days and hated it.
What problems, if any, will you have if you get tuned with a test pipe and use a HFC most of the time? I want to get tuned for the test pipe but use a cat for everyday driving.
I wish I had this post a couple months ago when some clowns were arguing with me how the gains from a cat delete were negligible over a HFC
It feels like you turned the boost down 3-4psi when you put one of them on after having a cat delete. I'm sure some can attest to how bad it is when you put the stock cat on after a delete to pass inspection...
It feels like you turned the boost down 3-4psi when you put one of them on after having a cat delete. I'm sure some can attest to how bad it is when you put the stock cat on after a delete to pass inspection...
That is my cars dyno sheet, i have a full buschur TBE with magnaflow, and o2 housing and slowboy racing exhaust manifold. The difference in the car is very noticable from the hi flow to the test pipe, the car pulls harder especially at redline. The sound is tolerable at low speeds and cruising around town and at WOT is sounds amazing but loud. I have the cosworth cams which give it a very nice sounding lopey idle which i particularly like. The boost is set at 23psi. Thanx again Al and Jimmy at "the shop" great job with my car. I'll see you guyz at the end of the summer to put in that alchy kit.
Thread Starter
Account Disabled
iTrader: (91)
Joined: Sep 2003
Posts: 16,850
Likes: 0
From: 2003 Evo VIII - Silver
I have an idea for a great product
Get the QTP guys to make a electric valve that switches from a catted side to a test pipe side with a switch in the car
One side is quiet and smog friendly - the other is good for more power and sound
At this point they have it do it dumps to the air which makes the car stupidly loud
I dont see why plumbing could noty be installed to switch between say a high flow cat or resonator on one side and a straight through pipe on the other
Get the QTP guys to make a electric valve that switches from a catted side to a test pipe side with a switch in the car
One side is quiet and smog friendly - the other is good for more power and sound
At this point they have it do it dumps to the air which makes the car stupidly loud
I dont see why plumbing could noty be installed to switch between say a high flow cat or resonator on one side and a straight through pipe on the other
Thread Starter
Account Disabled
iTrader: (91)
Joined: Sep 2003
Posts: 16,850
Likes: 0
From: 2003 Evo VIII - Silver
That is my cars dyno sheet, i have a full buschur TBE with magnaflow, and o2 housing and slowboy racing exhaust manifold. The difference in the car is very noticable from the hi flow to the test pipe, the car pulls harder especially at redline. The sound is tolerable at low speeds and cruising around town and at WOT is sounds amazing but loud. I have the cosworth cams which give it a very nice sounding lopey idle which i particularly like. The boost is set at 23psi. Thanx again Al and Jimmy at "the shop" great job with my car. I'll see you guyz at the end of the summer to put in that alchy kit.
Alchy will get you just over 400 tq and 380 whp or so on our dyno
I have an idea for a great product
Get the QTP guys to make a electric valve that switches from a catted side to a test pipe side with a switch in the car
One side is quiet and smog friendly - the other is good for more power and sound
At this point they have it do it dumps to the air which makes the car stupidly loud
I dont see why plumbing could noty be installed to switch between say a high flow cat or resonator on one side and a straight through pipe on the other
Get the QTP guys to make a electric valve that switches from a catted side to a test pipe side with a switch in the car
One side is quiet and smog friendly - the other is good for more power and sound
At this point they have it do it dumps to the air which makes the car stupidly loud
I dont see why plumbing could noty be installed to switch between say a high flow cat or resonator on one side and a straight through pipe on the other
Here we have the same car with same mods - same boost - same fuel tested with and without a high flow cat
One pull is with the high flow cat - the other pull is with a test pipe and some minor tuning adjustmentys (it went lean due to inhanced air flow)
Just wanted to show you guys what kind of power you loose with a high flow cat
I think my tuning looks real smooth on that sheet also

One pull is with the high flow cat - the other pull is with a test pipe and some minor tuning adjustmentys (it went lean due to inhanced air flow)
Just wanted to show you guys what kind of power you loose with a high flow cat
I think my tuning looks real smooth on that sheet also

Thread Starter
Account Disabled
iTrader: (91)
Joined: Sep 2003
Posts: 16,850
Likes: 0
From: 2003 Evo VIII - Silver
The car was simply too lean just pulling the HFC it needed some fuel to be safe
Doesn't the MAF sensor usually adjust for minor exhaust mods? I'm surprised that it changed the AFR that much. Could it have been pulling some timing with the cat and then timing went up with the test pipe (thereby leaning it out)? I'm just wondering if there was a timing change also between the two runs.
Doesn't the MAF sensor usually adjust for minor exhaust mods? I'm surprised that it changed the AFR that much. Could it have been pulling some timing with the cat and then timing went up with the test pipe (thereby leaning it out)? I'm just wondering if there was a timing change also between the two runs.
I dont think it went THAT lean to to warrant pulling significant timing out, but just from the added flow and going a little lean, the power gained would be mucho compared to maybe 1 degree of timing.
Was this car tuned with the cat first? Or was the intent to tune with the test pipe, so the pass with the cat was just a baseline?
Al, please don't take these questions as an attack. They are not meant that way at all.
Thanks.








