Lets say I wanted to get 18's for my evo, of these tires, which would you go with?

I've narrowed it down to my budget....for the 235/40/18...they're all in the 140 or less category. I'm looking for good mileage and decent grip. I've had kumho 712's and thought they were no good...not going there again.

1. Falken ST115
2. Falken FK451
3. Nitto NT555
4. Pirelli Nero
5. Toyo FZ4(new one)

 

I have the pirelli's. I needed all-season tires to help me through the winters in Nebraska so I compromised some performance for practicality. They have decent grip but not as well as stock Yokohama's. They work well for everyday driving though. I don't know how well they stack up performance wise to the other tires listed.

 

Try the Kumho ASX's Ultra high performance All-Season tire. $93 at tirerack.com.
I have em and love them!

 

Get azenis and not the st-115 get the sports.

 

wow, no ones ever had the Nitto's? Hmmmm...ASX's hum... maybe I'll look into those. I doubt Disc. Tire will have'm in stock though. My particular local shop still says the kumho MX doesn't exist. LOL