Since someone threw the ZR1 in there, I thought I would contribute this. But out of the original three I would have to go with the Camaro.

 

I voted for the Camaro out of the 3 choices, but it's a little unfair comparing a Mustang GT to cars costing $10K+ more. Plus, these are supposed to be top models, so the Shelby GT500 should have been the option for the Mustang instead of a regular GT.

 

I like the look of the camaro, but it is WAY too heavy- so I say Mustang

 

There's really nothing new about the '09 Rustang.

Regardless, all 3 are too heavy. They're all pretty ugly. I'd rather have a used C6 Vette than any of these 3.

 

What muscle? I see a bunch of 21st Century plastic cars trying to encourage sales by using familiar names..

 

yuck

 

never been a big mopar fan but the challenger does look pretty sick!, id probably end up picking the camaro though!

 

...Uh.....None of the above^^^

 

SS for sho w/LS3

BTW you have a pic of the RS up there not the SS (it is a small differents..)

 

other than the exception of my arms, corvette z06

 

mustang= teh ghey

camaro or challenger

 

You can probably get the 500 hp mustang for about the price of the first 2, now that the hype and markup has died down, so GT may not be the right one to compare.

 

the camaro will be my next car as soon as i pay off this evo.

 

What he said.

 

i think that camaro is so damn ugly. it looks horrible. its huge but i guess its a big leap forward from there past models.

Mustangs are ugly and look the same as they have since like 04.

The challenger looks pretty good considering it atleast somewhat resembles an actuall classic muscle car. But that thing is heavy car.

I would never buy any of them. Only american muscle worth buying is the corvette and viper