When will the ECU *REALLY* pull timing?
Originally Posted by C6C6CH3vo
So how do I do that - to get the 0 - 255 octane # log for my Evo scan with the Data.xml from Jack and Banks? Sorry - ADD
Originally Posted by Rob W.
Thanks, Stew. I found that file in the Octane thread, and educated myself by searching under 'data.xml'. So, I noticed that file doesn't have vehicle speed or afr in it. Are those variables still not necessarily verified?
Is there a list anywhere of confirmed new channels, or is the only certain one Octane Number at this point?
Sorry this thread has drifted off topic a bit, but it's useful for us newbies.
Is there a list anywhere of confirmed new channels, or is the only certain one Octane Number at this point?
Sorry this thread has drifted off topic a bit, but it's useful for us newbies.
I agree with whoever said: "Why remove a safety net?"
Realize that Al is the only Evo ECU flasher by trade that makes these values the same. Do any of you honestly think that he's right and everyone else is wrong?
I'll take the extra safety for my car!
Realize that Al is the only Evo ECU flasher by trade that makes these values the same. Do any of you honestly think that he's right and everyone else is wrong?
I'll take the extra safety for my car!
Originally Posted by Noize
I agree with whoever said: "Why remove a safety net?"
Realize that Al is the only Evo ECU flasher by trade that makes these values the same. Do any of you honestly think that he's right and everyone else is wrong?
I'll take the extra safety for my car!
Realize that Al is the only Evo ECU flasher by trade that makes these values the same. Do any of you honestly think that he's right and everyone else is wrong?
I'll take the extra safety for my car!
Basically, say all is good and you are running safely in the high octane maps. A few events occur and the ECU's safety algorithms kick in and keep the car running safe, while lowering the octane number. All is cleared there, and the events have passed, while you were still running safe. You would now be running in the low octane maps, safe enough again for high octane maps, but the Octane number still has to slowly raise itself back up before the ECU decides all is clear.
Wasn't it posted that it could take days until the octane number reaches the value of 255 again, unless the battery is unplugged??
Yeah, by doing so you may maintain timing and fuel performance durring nuicance faults, however, your removing a margin of safety in case of fuel pump/supply fail, bad gas, or boost malfunction.
But how much can a lo oct map help in some cases as these - the difference between a half damaged engine or totally gone engine
But how much can a lo oct map help in some cases as these - the difference between a half damaged engine or totally gone engine
Originally Posted by C6C6CH3vo
Yeah, by doing so you may maintain timing and fuel performance durring nuicance faults, however, your removing a margin of safety in case of fuel pump/supply fail, bad gas, or boost malfunction.
But how much can a lo oct map help in some cases as these - the difference between a half damaged engine or totally gone engine
But how much can a lo oct map help in some cases as these - the difference between a half damaged engine or totally gone engine
Fuel ratios are always a balance.. Too rich can cause "Knock events" that arent detonation but sudden abrupt quenching of the combustion.. I found that 10.5-11.5 are ranges where you won't get that quench.. anything leaner you risk detonation under some circumstances, anything much richer than 10.2 and you may get some quench (your ignition system quality and the size of your gap have a direct impact on this)
However.. here's my data, this is from several weeks of logging and comparison..
3 or more counts of knock will trigger the timing to pull, it will quickly return if the knock subsides in the decay time (2-3 samples ) This correlates to approximately 1.65-1.8v of noise on the knock sensor.. Bigger spikes pull more timing.. If the knock value does not decline in the decay period, it will begin to affect the octane number.. It will continue to do that until the knock count drops to 1-2 with sporatic anomalous spikes in some areas.. If it shifts the octane number, it will return over time to 255 after no notable event occurs.
Al is correct about how the knock protection works.. Sustained knock is typically due to bad gas, or other conditions, and that what the low octane maps are for.. Do I recommend flattening them, well no.. but they are used for providing safety should the car overboost, or get bad gas, and have bouts of sustained knock over a duration longer than what the knock protection algorithms do.
If you notice the stock maps on the 03 (And I think other years) have -10 (Generally the negative timing) in some of the high load cells at lower RPM.. That is basically cutting the power to the car and releasing excess combustion should you overboost at low RPM. This guarantees you won't build up enough cylinder pressure to blow a headgasket or get a very lean condition due to overrunning your maps. This is used as a momentary safety before fuel/boost cut kicks in. (on the stock ECU)
The reason some of us are seeing these negative timing numbers is we're modifying the car, removing boost cut, removing fuel cut, putting on an MBC that increases boost and spooling faster, etc.... so on the stock turbo it places you squarely in the safety portions of the map.
However.. here's my data, this is from several weeks of logging and comparison..
3 or more counts of knock will trigger the timing to pull, it will quickly return if the knock subsides in the decay time (2-3 samples ) This correlates to approximately 1.65-1.8v of noise on the knock sensor.. Bigger spikes pull more timing.. If the knock value does not decline in the decay period, it will begin to affect the octane number.. It will continue to do that until the knock count drops to 1-2 with sporatic anomalous spikes in some areas.. If it shifts the octane number, it will return over time to 255 after no notable event occurs.
Al is correct about how the knock protection works.. Sustained knock is typically due to bad gas, or other conditions, and that what the low octane maps are for.. Do I recommend flattening them, well no.. but they are used for providing safety should the car overboost, or get bad gas, and have bouts of sustained knock over a duration longer than what the knock protection algorithms do.
If you notice the stock maps on the 03 (And I think other years) have -10 (Generally the negative timing) in some of the high load cells at lower RPM.. That is basically cutting the power to the car and releasing excess combustion should you overboost at low RPM. This guarantees you won't build up enough cylinder pressure to blow a headgasket or get a very lean condition due to overrunning your maps. This is used as a momentary safety before fuel/boost cut kicks in. (on the stock ECU)
The reason some of us are seeing these negative timing numbers is we're modifying the car, removing boost cut, removing fuel cut, putting on an MBC that increases boost and spooling faster, etc.... so on the stock turbo it places you squarely in the safety portions of the map.
Originally Posted by Stew
Honestly, I'm not sure if other channels have been verified. I've only added Octane Number so far. Also, I know I've seen some threads on here about the wideband AFR feature working or not working properly, but haven't looked into it at all yet since my car is still without an installed motor thus I have more pending issues at the moment 

Originally Posted by Stew
Just download the file attached above, and replace the current data.xml file (located in C:\Program Files\EvoScan\EvoScan v0.8\DataSettings if you installed in the default location) with the downloaded version, and you will have a checkbox for "Octane Number".


Originally Posted by MalibuJack
Fuel ratios are always a balance.. Too rich can cause "Knock events" that arent detonation but sudden abrupt quenching of the combustion.. I found that 10.5-11.5 are ranges where you won't get that quench.. anything leaner you risk detonation under some circumstances, anything much richer than 10.2 and you may get some quench (your ignition system quality and the size of your gap have a direct impact on this)
3 or more counts of knock will trigger the timing to pull, it will quickly return if the knock subsides in the decay time (2-3 samples ) This correlates to approximately 1.65-1.8v of noise on the knock sensor.. Bigger spikes pull more timing
You can run a bit leaner if you run lower boost.. but generally you aren't gaining much by running any leaner than around 11.5, at least you are trading off safety for the diminishing reward..
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
shiv@vishnu
Evo Engine / Turbo / Drivetrain
213
Aug 5, 2005 03:05 PM









