Tial BOV experiances...
#1
Tial BOV experiances...
Hey guys,
I have noticed that with the stock spring in the TIAL BOV, I get some compressor surge when I come off the loud pedal from a part throttle condition. So, I called up Buschur Racing and they sold me the two other springs that are optional for the Tial BOV. The stock spring is 11 lbs per inch of compression (not 11 psi, these springs are measured just like the springs for your suspension). The first spring I tried was 9 lbs per inch and the last one was 7 lbs per inch. If you are still using a MAS setup, you need the 9 lb per inch spring because it keeps the BOV closed at idle for good idle quality when venting to atmosphere. Since I am converted over to speed density I am using the 7 lb spring and loving it!
I highly recomend this spring swap to anyone with a tial BOV. I would love to get a little vacuum pump with a guage and check each spring. I may do that in the future, but it is sort of a pain in the a$$ to swap them out.... so don't count on it
Keith
I have noticed that with the stock spring in the TIAL BOV, I get some compressor surge when I come off the loud pedal from a part throttle condition. So, I called up Buschur Racing and they sold me the two other springs that are optional for the Tial BOV. The stock spring is 11 lbs per inch of compression (not 11 psi, these springs are measured just like the springs for your suspension). The first spring I tried was 9 lbs per inch and the last one was 7 lbs per inch. If you are still using a MAS setup, you need the 9 lb per inch spring because it keeps the BOV closed at idle for good idle quality when venting to atmosphere. Since I am converted over to speed density I am using the 7 lb spring and loving it!
I highly recomend this spring swap to anyone with a tial BOV. I would love to get a little vacuum pump with a guage and check each spring. I may do that in the future, but it is sort of a pain in the a$$ to swap them out.... so don't count on it
Keith
#3
Evolving Member
iTrader: (10)
Join Date: Sep 2004
Location: Oak Harbor, WA
Posts: 165
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I was just talking about this a couple minutes ago. How much boost are you running and does it hold just as well as the heavy spring? I've got the rattlesnake fluttering sound from the intake. Its annoying but seems to run fine. (speed density) I was warned third hand by turbo trix who tuned it that a lighter spring wouldn't hold boost as well. Was it an easy swap?
https://www.evolutionm.net/forums/sh...d.php?t=103859
https://www.evolutionm.net/forums/sh...d.php?t=103859
#4
The swap is real simple, but you have to be carful when pulling the last bolt out because that is a LOT of spring tension with the stock spring.
The upper chamber of the BOV has a larger surface area than the surface area of the popet valve itself, so when you are under boost you have more pounds of force pushing the valve shut than you have trying to force it open even if you had no spring at all ( the same pounds per square inch over a larger number of square inches). As soon as you go WOT the vacuum holding the valve open goes away and the spring forces it shut, then when you build boost the positive pressure in the intake manifold seals the valve tight.
I have data logs from before and after the spring swap, and I have the same boost spike and tapper as I did before, with peak boost of 23 psi. No leaks!
Keith
PS: Speed density huh? You running AEM EMS? I just ordered the GM boost control solenoid because I am tired of the "spike and tapper" behavior of manual controlers.
The upper chamber of the BOV has a larger surface area than the surface area of the popet valve itself, so when you are under boost you have more pounds of force pushing the valve shut than you have trying to force it open even if you had no spring at all ( the same pounds per square inch over a larger number of square inches). As soon as you go WOT the vacuum holding the valve open goes away and the spring forces it shut, then when you build boost the positive pressure in the intake manifold seals the valve tight.
I have data logs from before and after the spring swap, and I have the same boost spike and tapper as I did before, with peak boost of 23 psi. No leaks!
Keith
PS: Speed density huh? You running AEM EMS? I just ordered the GM boost control solenoid because I am tired of the "spike and tapper" behavior of manual controlers.
Last edited by Fourdoor; Oct 17, 2004 at 01:41 PM.
#5
Evolving Member
iTrader: (10)
Join Date: Sep 2004
Location: Oak Harbor, WA
Posts: 165
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I'm excited to try the spring. I'll call Buschur tommorow and order it, or maybe both. How much $?
Yes I'm running AEM EMS tuned by Turbotrix. I haven't tweaked it myself, they're the experts. I'm running a manual boost controller right now. Whats up with the GM part? The car holds boost great at WOT up to 4th. WOT in 5th is a schizophrenic nightmare. Boost bounces around at reduced levels, shakes and does all kind of wacky stuff. Part throttle in any gear is a little unpredicable also, and cold idle with the ac compressor on needs a little gas to stay alive. I know the tune is quirky, but i don't want to mess with it because the WOT map is so badass. If TT couldn't tune it out I doubt I can. If nothing else I hope I can get rid of the comp surge. It was also tuned for 94 and I'm running 92-3.
Yes I'm running AEM EMS tuned by Turbotrix. I haven't tweaked it myself, they're the experts. I'm running a manual boost controller right now. Whats up with the GM part? The car holds boost great at WOT up to 4th. WOT in 5th is a schizophrenic nightmare. Boost bounces around at reduced levels, shakes and does all kind of wacky stuff. Part throttle in any gear is a little unpredicable also, and cold idle with the ac compressor on needs a little gas to stay alive. I know the tune is quirky, but i don't want to mess with it because the WOT map is so badass. If TT couldn't tune it out I doubt I can. If nothing else I hope I can get rid of the comp surge. It was also tuned for 94 and I'm running 92-3.
#7
Originally Posted by FlyNavy
I'm excited to try the spring. I'll call Buschur tommorow and order it, or maybe both. How much $?
Yes I'm running AEM EMS tuned by Turbotrix. I haven't tweaked it myself, they're the experts. I'm running a manual boost controller right now. Whats up with the GM part? The car holds boost great at WOT up to 4th. WOT in 5th is a schizophrenic nightmare. Boost bounces around at reduced levels, shakes and does all kind of wacky stuff. Part throttle in any gear is a little unpredicable also, and cold idle with the ac compressor on needs a little gas to stay alive. I know the tune is quirky, but i don't want to mess with it because the WOT map is so badass. If TT couldn't tune it out I doubt I can. If nothing else I hope I can get rid of the comp surge. It was also tuned for 94 and I'm running 92-3.
Yes I'm running AEM EMS tuned by Turbotrix. I haven't tweaked it myself, they're the experts. I'm running a manual boost controller right now. Whats up with the GM part? The car holds boost great at WOT up to 4th. WOT in 5th is a schizophrenic nightmare. Boost bounces around at reduced levels, shakes and does all kind of wacky stuff. Part throttle in any gear is a little unpredicable also, and cold idle with the ac compressor on needs a little gas to stay alive. I know the tune is quirky, but i don't want to mess with it because the WOT map is so badass. If TT couldn't tune it out I doubt I can. If nothing else I hope I can get rid of the comp surge. It was also tuned for 94 and I'm running 92-3.
About boost control: Using a manual boost controler, you are probably getting a spike and tapper just like everyone else.... do some data logging with the EMS and you will see it much easier than you will notice it on a boost gauge. I am not sure why you are getting strange responses in 5th, that is just messed up! Using the GM boost control solenoid you can set your AEM EMS to operate as an electronic boost controler.
About cold idle tune: With HKS 272 cams, Tym over at Buschur Racing did an awesom job with the cold start and warm up maps, only thing I had to do to make it perfect was adjust the base idle set screw. That may be enough to fix your problem as well. No problems with AC on or anything! The WOT maps were also great for a base map. The daily driving portion of the map was way rich though. I have it tuned great now thanks to having the built in UEGO wide band. Talk to Turbo Trix if adjusting the base idle set screw dosn't help, and I am sure they can help you out. You really need to get the 5th gear strange boost behavior worked out though.... that could be a problem!
Later,
Keith
Trending Topics
#8
Originally Posted by ASTROEVO
WOW.....i have been running the tia for a while now on my car.... speed density....might try this...but i am running alot of boost...let me know how it works
For anyone reading this who is still running a MAS, using the 9 lb spring (white spring) will leave the BOV closed at idle for better idle caracteristics with a MAS.... but you do still have some compressor surge. Not as much, but you still have some. Oh, and of course with a MAS you will go rich when shifting due to venting to atmosphere.
Later,
Keith
#10
Originally Posted by evo81
so is it ok to run a tial with mas?a flash should help with the running rich with a vta bov?i'm still getting this bov even if it has a little compressor surge.
Later,
Keith
#11
Evolved Member
iTrader: (7)
Join Date: Jul 2003
Location: NYC/NNJ
Posts: 510
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
If you are running a mas I wouldn't be using a VTA bov.... your car does not run correctly.... You are running super rich when you do that.... the air is measured at the MAS and that is how the fuel is calculated... so if you dump air out after then you are flooding it with fuel which ='s poor performance and will also foul up your plugs quicker... and just isn't good for the car... The tial is ment for running a standalone...NOT MAS.... also the Tial BOV is rated for up to 35 PSI.....
#12
Originally Posted by Grod101
If you are running a mas I wouldn't be using a VTA bov.... your car does not run correctly.... You are running super rich when you do that.... the air is measured at the MAS and that is how the fuel is calculated... so if you dump air out after then you are flooding it with fuel which ='s poor performance and will also foul up your plugs quicker... and just isn't good for the car... The tial is ment for running a standalone...NOT MAS.... also the Tial BOV is rated for up to 35 PSI.....
I agree 100% that running vent to atmosphere on a BOV isn't a good thing to do with a car that is still running a MAS. I just wanted to point out (for the 100's perhaps 1000's that do this) that going to the lightest spring would be a bad thing for them to do
Keith
#13
Evolving Member
iTrader: (10)
Join Date: Sep 2004
Location: Oak Harbor, WA
Posts: 165
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Whats the advantage for us standalone guys keeping it closed at idle? I just ordered the black spring and am curious why it would benefit to washer it closed. Will this affect its performance in other regimes?
#14
Originally Posted by FlyNavy
Whats the advantage for us standalone guys keeping it closed at idle? I just ordered the black spring and am curious why it would benefit to washer it closed. Will this affect its performance in other regimes?
Nope. I can't think of any performance reason for it. I just like the look of it closed when the hood is open with the engine running
Keith
#15
Evolving Member
iTrader: (10)
Join Date: Sep 2004
Location: Oak Harbor, WA
Posts: 165
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Gotcha. Thats as good a reason as any for a car guy. I spent the better part of Saturday afternoon making all my dash and internal lights red. HP gain=0.
BR said it'd take them a week or so to order the part, I can't wait to try it. Now that I know what that flutter is I notice surging all the time even when romping on it.
BR said it'd take them a week or so to order the part, I can't wait to try it. Now that I know what that flutter is I notice surging all the time even when romping on it.