View Poll Results: greddy type s - how many springs ?
stock - two springs



40
34.19%
mod - single spring



77
65.81%
Voters: 117. You may not vote on this poll
poll: greddy type s - two stock springs or single spring mod
Originally Posted by 93civEJ1
why would you pick a race based on if they have the single spring or not? I have the single spring. Seems to work fine for me...Yet I havent tried putting the other spring back in either though.
Mine is the RRE version which has a recycling tube in the adapter that goes between the two chambers. It is posible that that tube is the culprit for me being able to hold only 19 to 20lbs. But it sound like most of you are more interested in the whoosh sound and smooth idle. I don't care about whoosh, and my idle is fine. There is no free lunch, though, and I do put up with worse-than-stock drivability issues with this BOV set for max power.
Last edited by Smogrunner; Jan 24, 2005 at 07:51 PM.
I am running the Type-S with stock cams and the single spring mod. Also the lower (smaller) port is open. I started with the adjustment screw at about 2 turns in. I have gone up another 4-5 turns and am still getting a weird flutter or stutter at mid to high rpm, light throttle openings. Like when trying to accellerate slowly at freeway speeds, then letting off the gas a little to hold speed. The car jerks and the BOV makes a chut-chut-chut sound.
It works great and sounds awesome when driving hard, it is only when trying to cruise on the highway that it gives me trouble. Any suggestions?
EVOlutionary
It works great and sounds awesome when driving hard, it is only when trying to cruise on the highway that it gives me trouble. Any suggestions?
EVOlutionary
Thread Starter
Evolved Member
iTrader: (56)
Joined: Sep 2004
Posts: 11,132
Likes: 1
From: Western NY
Originally Posted by EVOlutionary
It works great and sounds awesome when driving hard, it is only when trying to cruise on the highway that it gives me trouble. Any suggestions?
EVOlutionary
EVOlutionary
Originally Posted by Smogrunner
I'd love to race any of you in the 1/4 regardless of turbo or mods if you only have the single spring installed. The stocker is better than the single spring Greddy type s and is free....
I don't agree! I made over 24 passses last year comparing 1g, crushed 1g, type s with large spring, small spring, always only using the upper port. I made several 11.90 passes with ONLY THE SMALL SPRING tuned about 5 turns in. On the two 1g's the car ran 12.02 to 12.18, crushed was always faster. The type s would run 11.92 to 12.05 no matter what spring I was running and MPH was always within 1 mph. Tells me none of combos from the type s were leaking. Now, this may not be the case with everybody so bolt on YOUR PARTS and go do some testing (which smoggy does).
Now that I have the big turbo on and running 26psi daily I did put the large spring in and have it turned in about 3 turns, seems to hold perfect. I will let you know when the track opens.
Originally Posted by 4ringturncoat
I don't agree! I made over 24 passses last year comparing 1g, crushed 1g, type s with large spring, small spring, always only using the upper port. I made several 11.90 passes with ONLY THE SMALL SPRING tuned about 5 turns in. On the two 1g's the car ran 12.02 to 12.18, crushed was always faster. The type s would run 11.92 to 12.05 no matter what spring I was running and MPH was always within 1 mph. Tells me none of combos from the type s were leaking. Now, this may not be the case with everybody so bolt on YOUR PARTS and go do some testing (which smoggy does).
Now that I have the big turbo on and running 26psi daily I did put the large spring in and have it turned in about 3 turns, seems to hold perfect. I will let you know when the track opens.
Now that I have the big turbo on and running 26psi daily I did put the large spring in and have it turned in about 3 turns, seems to hold perfect. I will let you know when the track opens.
Thanks. That was a very informative post. I definitely need to do some more testing. I've blocked off the little tube that goes between the two chambers, have both springs in, and have them tightened down so that there are only 4 or 5 threads left on the adjustment screw. With this setting, I know I'm maximized for racing, but I get off boost flutter/bucking at steady speeds and the car is more stall prone than with the stock BOV. The last time I tried the single spring, the little tube was set up to recirculate. Maybe with it blocked off, it will hold boost like yours.
In any event, I'll probably just leave both springs in and lighten setting as much as possible to make it an even smoother everyday driver.
FYI, I am running the RMR intake and I/C pipes. I had the problem even before installing the I/C pipe.
A question - on the picture on the first page, what is the blue hose on the 2nd BOV nipple connected to? Also - it appears that my BOV is different; the secondary nipple is in a different location than the one on the first page of this thread. Does anyone know of a first and second design?
EVOlutionary
A question - on the picture on the first page, what is the blue hose on the 2nd BOV nipple connected to? Also - it appears that my BOV is different; the secondary nipple is in a different location than the one on the first page of this thread. Does anyone know of a first and second design?
EVOlutionary
Last edited by EVOlutionary; Jan 26, 2005 at 04:36 PM.
Originally Posted by Smogrunner
Simple, the single spring feels and works great, but will leak boost big time. I have personally tested mine with the single spring tightened down very far and still couldn't get it to hold more than 19 or 20 psi. My stock diverter valve holds 21 reliably. I put in both springs and BAMMMM! 22lbs on pump and 26lbs on race.
Originally Posted by EVOlutionary
FYI, I am running the RMR intake and I/C pipes. I had the problem even before installing the I/C pipe.
A question - on the picture on the first page, what is the blue hose on the 2nd BOV nipple connected to? Also - it appears that my BOV is different; the secondary nipple is in a different location than the one on the first page of this thread. Does anyone know of a first and second design?
EVOlutionary
A question - on the picture on the first page, what is the blue hose on the 2nd BOV nipple connected to? Also - it appears that my BOV is different; the secondary nipple is in a different location than the one on the first page of this thread. Does anyone know of a first and second design?
EVOlutionary
it sounds better, a little different, but it leaks boost badly, at least thats what my gauge said, also i think the 05's run a tiny little bit more. i like the sound but am thinking about switching back to stock if i go to the track.
Joined: Dec 2003
Posts: 540
Likes: 2
From: home of the Field Artillery, Ft. Sill OK
Originally Posted by 93civEJ1
i run straight 272's with the single spring tightened down pretty well, seems to hold fine.
same here... no issues at all.
Well, pick your poison: David Buschur and Shiv both don't trust BOVs not to leak. Shiv recommends very stiff springed aftermarket BOVs and DB just said in another post that he doens't even use BOVs in some of his cars in order to eliminate the possibility of them leaking altogether. Drivability suffers somewhat though on both of these approaches...


