Is an Oil Catch Can worth getting?
#16
EvoM Staff Alumni
iTrader: (106)
Hey guys here are my 2cents. I ran around with a little k&n style air filter for about a year, leaked oil and the car seemed to not like having the line from the valve cover to the intake pipe disconnected. For the same price if not $1 more than a k&n style filter you can pick up one of the Campbell Hausfeld mini general purpose filters. These are great because of their price, size, transparency and excellent oil catch function. No offense but I just could never justify paying the high prices for something like a catch can.
#17
Evolved Member
iTrader: (2)
For you guys that mentioned that you are running a breather filter on the valve cover where the breather hose used to be, I would suggest that you either put it back to stock or put an inline filter/catchcan of some sort.
Unless you have an EMS that can compensate for it, you will be getting uncounted air into the intake manifold. Anytime that you are under a vacuum condition in the intake manifold (idle and cruise), the PCV valve opens. Air is then pulled through the breather hose, through the valve cover, and through the PCV valve and into the inake manifold. In stock condition, since the breather hose is connected to the intake pipe, that air is 'counted' by the MAF, but if you use a breather filter, that is 'uncounted' air that is getting into the combustion chamber. The MAF never knew about it, so it only instructs the injectors to fire the amount of fuel for the 'counted' air through the MAF. This will cause you to run lean at idle and cruise, possibly causing stalling problems, etc.
Eric
Unless you have an EMS that can compensate for it, you will be getting uncounted air into the intake manifold. Anytime that you are under a vacuum condition in the intake manifold (idle and cruise), the PCV valve opens. Air is then pulled through the breather hose, through the valve cover, and through the PCV valve and into the inake manifold. In stock condition, since the breather hose is connected to the intake pipe, that air is 'counted' by the MAF, but if you use a breather filter, that is 'uncounted' air that is getting into the combustion chamber. The MAF never knew about it, so it only instructs the injectors to fire the amount of fuel for the 'counted' air through the MAF. This will cause you to run lean at idle and cruise, possibly causing stalling problems, etc.
Eric
#22
Originally Posted by mitsuorder
I actually tapped a hole in my BR mas pipe, screwed in a nipple, steel epoxied around it on the outside for a nice seal, and then dremeled the excessive threaded portion down smooth on the inside, works well
Picture please Did you notice in difference in gas mileage, idling, etc?
#23
Evolved Member
iTrader: (23)
the air compressor filter works great, but what works better is if you take out the valve at the bottom of the bowl and attach a hose to it, connecting to a valve that you can open and close manually, I have this setup and I never have to get my hands in there to unscrew the bowl and dump it, I just pop the hood, loosen a knob, wait a sec, tighten the knob, and close the hood.
#25
Evolved Member
iTrader: (3)
Join Date: Sep 2003
Location: Agrestic
Posts: 1,394
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by mitsuorder
<snip> For the same price if not $1 more than a k&n style filter you can pick up one of the Campbell Hausfeld mini general purpose filters. These are great because of their price, size, transparency and excellent oil catch function. No offense but I just could never justify paying the high prices for something like a catch can.
#27
Originally Posted by honki24
yep, pulls right out with some needle nose pliers (and the oil drains into my wheel well in case anyone cares)
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
evolution253
Evo How Tos / Installations
2
Jul 23, 2009 02:47 PM
letMeIn
For Sale/WTB - Engine / Drivetrain / Power
4
Jan 3, 2009 10:45 AM