Originally Posted by Warrtalon

You shouldn't be stuck bewtween those tires, because you shouldn't be using either of those tires. The main thing is you shouldn't go through the large expense of 18" rims and 18" tires while getting wheels with the same WIDTH as stock. That removes the whole point of getting rims, which is to improve performance. You can't do that with larger diameter rims that have the same width as stock. You gain nothing if you get 18x8s except maybe some looks (subjective). Go with an 18X8.5 or 18X9 and get a good 255/35-18 or so...