Stock ECU Help
Stock ECU Help
Long story short, I dropped my car off at TPG months ago to get tuned and they are having trouble/stumped as to what is causing this issue, so I'm hoping someone here has some experience and or insight.
The ecu is not responding to any fuel trim changes or changes to lean out the car, it's running super rich all the time and no matter how much fuel they pull off the map it's still really rich. They've also said the car starts like normal with the injector scaling at 0 some how. They've checked all sensors, tried another stock ecu, had the injectors re cleaned, replaced the O2 sensor, and gone through just about everything to no avail. As a last ditch test, they tried a Haltech and all of a sudden it started responding like it should. So not really sure where to go from here as I really don't want to buy a Haltech for a stock motor bolt-ons Evo 9, as that just seems like overkill.
The ecu is not responding to any fuel trim changes or changes to lean out the car, it's running super rich all the time and no matter how much fuel they pull off the map it's still really rich. They've also said the car starts like normal with the injector scaling at 0 some how. They've checked all sensors, tried another stock ecu, had the injectors re cleaned, replaced the O2 sensor, and gone through just about everything to no avail. As a last ditch test, they tried a Haltech and all of a sudden it started responding like it should. So not really sure where to go from here as I really don't want to buy a Haltech for a stock motor bolt-ons Evo 9, as that just seems like overkill.
Based on the info you provided they either don't know what they are doing, are trying to con you into buying a haltech, or both. Months to get a tune is already a huge red flag though even without the other side of the story.
Here's a couple responses from them over the past few months regarding what was tested etc.
We looked over the car found a few issues. The TPS wasn't installed correctly and wasn't working, we fixed that. The throttle cable was too tight holding the throttle open so that is taken care of as well. The catch can off the manifold can't work the way it's hooked up, it would just pressurize the crank case how it's hooked up so I just removed that fitting and blocked it off. The biggest issue which I am still trying to sort though is the fueling. The car I believe is on pump gas currently. Regardless of how much fuel I take away from the tune the car just runs 10.0 afr. Either the fuel lines are backwards, the regulator is bad, or an injector is stuck open. I am still sorting through that at the moment.
Unfortunately no. The car still runs pig rich no matter what I try. I tried swapping map sensors, tps, put a fuel pressure gauge on the car. Verified mechanical timing. Swapped widebands to verify they are reading correctly. The next step would be trying a new ecu.
I already tried various different rom files from 2D to 3D speed density. I do have an ecu here I can test with. If that does not fix it we would need to start by removing the fuel system and checking everything over. If that does not work then possibly try a stand alone. If that doesn't work then there is more than likely a wiring issue. It almost acts like the engine is out of time or very low on compression or variable compression. Is the motor brand new?
You need to provide more details about why you brought your car to them and what mods you have done to it. Otherwise its pretty hard to judge the situation. IMO though it sounds like you are being strung along. All that stuff should have taken a competent shop ~ an hour to do. That's my expectation anyway, not having a shop myself but knowing how long it would take me to go through all that. The story doesn't add up to me either. Fixed TPS but tried swapping it anyway? Any novice could open evoscan and just press the pedal and verify the tps is working or not. A shop should have the tools to put vacuum/pressure on the map sensor and verify its logging correctly. A "tuner" shop should have a dyno with a wideband which could be used to verify your wideband. They have a fuel pressure gauge on the car so what is this about maybe tearing down the fuel system? That earlier bit about the fuel lines being mixed up also sounded very implausible. Take the car somewhere else and get a second opinion.
Car was to be switched to E85/SD and tuned on the FP green, injectors and GSC S2's i just put on. But ya a lot of their responses seemed like things that could've easily been seen via evoscan. Ya the fuel lines thing seemed impossible as the car wouldn't have started to begin with if that was the case. There's a lot of what if's on their end but at the end of the day they seem to be pushing the Haltech. The problem with going to another shop, which would be Tscomp in this case as he's actually not too much further from TPG, is that he decided that it would easier to ignore all messages and emails instead of taking my business from the get go. Otherwise the car would've been there from the start.
Evo 9 Stock Bottom End/Head
FIC 2150cc Injectors
GSC S2 w Kiggly Springs
Fp54 Green w 4in Intake
Ported Intake Manifold w 65mm TB
Ported FP Manifold
Omni 4Bar Map Sensor
4in FMIC and Piping
O2 Dump/3in DP
Evo 9 Stock Bottom End/Head
FIC 2150cc Injectors
GSC S2 w Kiggly Springs
Fp54 Green w 4in Intake
Ported Intake Manifold w 65mm TB
Ported FP Manifold
Omni 4Bar Map Sensor
4in FMIC and Piping
O2 Dump/3in DP
Last edited by GGevo09; Dec 15, 2020 at 07:20 AM.
Car was to be switched to e85 and tuned on the FP green, injectors and GSC S2's i just put on. But ya a lot of their responses seemed like things that could've easily been seen via evoscan. Ya the fuel lines thing seemed impossible as the car wouldn't have started to begin with if that was the case. There's a lot of what if's on their end but at the end of the day they seem to be pushing the Haltech. The problem with going to another shop, which would be Tscomp in this case as he's actually not too much further from TPG, is that he decided that it would easier to ignore all messages and emails instead of taking my business from the get go. Otherwise the car would've been there from the start.
Evo 9 Stock Bottom End/Head
FIC 2150cc Injectors
GSC S2 w Kiggly Springs
Fp54 Green w 4in Intake
Ported Intake Manifold w 65mm TB
Ported FP Manifold
Omni 4Bar Map Sensor
4in FMIC and Piping
O2 Dump/3in DP
Evo 9 Stock Bottom End/Head
FIC 2150cc Injectors
GSC S2 w Kiggly Springs
Fp54 Green w 4in Intake
Ported Intake Manifold w 65mm TB
Ported FP Manifold
Omni 4Bar Map Sensor
4in FMIC and Piping
O2 Dump/3in DP
Ya overall it's a fairly simple setup/build which is why I don't understand why this has became such a difficult task. Here's the most recent update today, from this it seems like the Haltech is over riding whatever is causing the issue that's present with the stock ecu, well if there's an issue that is, so who knows
We were able to finally get an EVO 9 Haltech adapter and threw together a quick map for it. The car immediately started to respond better. The car would actually lean out to normal AFR's and seemed to function well. Why does this work better than the stock ecu? I honestly am not sure what happens when the stock ecu is plugged in, but the car always goes super rich regardless of what it is told. With the Haltech it doesn't care about anything other than what we tell it so it works around whatever is happening. The only thing I can think of trying is ordering in one for you car specifically and try tuning it there. Let me know what you think.
Trending Topics
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
roydollabill
Evo X Engine Management / Tuning Forums
4
Jul 25, 2014 04:19 PM








