Advanced Turbo Element Discussion
i really don't think that it has to do with boost spike and fuel, mainly because ive seen the kit put to use in high boost like 9 psi and have no probles, HAVE to be abuse beyond what it can handle and installs
If it runs 80% IDC at 6psi, I have little faith above that. Yes, I know...fuel pressure, but 80% IDC is on the cusp of being dangerously high. And considering the overall lack of precision in the fuel delivery system...well...I have my doubts.
Originally posted by HobieKopek
Larger exhaust piping can cause boost spikes. That's not my problem. I bet you could easily solve any overboost problems with something simple like a boost controller anyway. If that doesn't help, it may be something else.
If you read my registry entry it tells you all the piping on my car is custom made.
I think the intent of this thread was to discuss in depth, turbo questions though, not so much our individual setups.
Larger exhaust piping can cause boost spikes. That's not my problem. I bet you could easily solve any overboost problems with something simple like a boost controller anyway. If that doesn't help, it may be something else.
If you read my registry entry it tells you all the piping on my car is custom made.
I think the intent of this thread was to discuss in depth, turbo questions though, not so much our individual setups.
Originally posted by Boni
Bigger piping causes more boost ? I am running 2.5 inch piping (turbo back) and im having boost problems. im gonna try to put my stock CAT back on and im trying to get a stock down pipe also. if this doesnt work what do you guys think? i already changed the spring in my wastegate and changed the vacuum line from the wastegate to the turbo.
Bigger piping causes more boost ? I am running 2.5 inch piping (turbo back) and im having boost problems. im gonna try to put my stock CAT back on and im trying to get a stock down pipe also. if this doesnt work what do you guys think? i already changed the spring in my wastegate and changed the vacuum line from the wastegate to the turbo.
Originally posted by sdhotwn
Something new to me that is worth a post
T28 turbos; T25 turbine + T3 compressor = T28
So which T3 compressor is on the T28?? I'm seeing several series's for the T3 compressor.
Something new to me that is worth a post
T28 turbos; T25 turbine + T3 compressor = T28
So which T3 compressor is on the T28?? I'm seeing several series's for the T3 compressor.
Originally posted by mobius97
That doesnt sound right. I thought all it shared was the housing, different wheels.
That doesnt sound right. I thought all it shared was the housing, different wheels.
Originally posted by sdhotwn
That was just what I found when I did some searching on the net. I've heard some feedback to the same from people as well... but at the least we know that the T28 is somewhat in between the T25 and the T3 (DUH!). I think the big question that it would be good to know the exact answer to is what compressor is in a T28 so that we could get maps for it.
That was just what I found when I did some searching on the net. I've heard some feedback to the same from people as well... but at the least we know that the T28 is somewhat in between the T25 and the T3 (DUH!). I think the big question that it would be good to know the exact answer to is what compressor is in a T28 so that we could get maps for it.
Last edited by mobius97; Nov 12, 2003 at 11:18 AM.
I have a question regarding ignition timing and boost. Since you're here Mobius maybe you'd know. If not, maybe someone will pick it up later. Is there a mathematical formula for it or is it more or less trial and error to prevent knock a little and still accelerate/drive smoovely. (not to be confused with smoothly
)
Man, I've gotta stop posting before I'm done with a thought.
Anyway, I'm kinda assuming it's trial and error, but doesn't that mean it'll be very difficult to advance/retard in areas of the ignition map you don't normally drive in? (like let's say -0.5bar and 6000rpms) But if you were to hit the point later in driving (granted this one is a bit extreme) couldn't it cause a bit of a suprise?
)Man, I've gotta stop posting before I'm done with a thought.
Anyway, I'm kinda assuming it's trial and error, but doesn't that mean it'll be very difficult to advance/retard in areas of the ignition map you don't normally drive in? (like let's say -0.5bar and 6000rpms) But if you were to hit the point later in driving (granted this one is a bit extreme) couldn't it cause a bit of a suprise?
Last edited by HobieKopek; Nov 12, 2003 at 09:52 AM.
I think that you are going to be stuck with trial and error, seeing every car is different. I myself am not too versed in this area but from what I know this is most likely the case.....perhaps try one of these methods: using higher octane gas, better cooling or lowering your boost. I guess is it just finding a balance that works for your car. Maybe there is some formula but I doubt it. Here is some info that might help written by someone else:
OK, if I can easily adjust boost, spark advance, and mixture ratios, (and to a certain extent
inlet air temp) what should I have more of to make the best power?
Excellent question. I don't know. I suspect that boost is worth more than spark advance, with
mixture ratio somewhere in the middle. If I had a PMS, a datalogger, and a dyno, I think I'd
set spark advance to about 2/3 of the possible range the computer provides, set the mixture a
little on the lean side, and then run the boost up to the detonation point, and back off a
little. Then I'd play with the mixture to see if I can get more power, or get the motor to
stand more boost. Once I've got a good WOT boost level and mixture ratio, then we see how much
more advance it can take. Maybe.
Note that we haven't taken inlet air temp or density into account here, nor have we allowed for
real-world factors like: how fast can the wastegate react to boost spikes? This is just an
educated guess. Bottom line? Lots of testing. Lots. And you can't get the inlet air temp too
cold.
OK, if I can easily adjust boost, spark advance, and mixture ratios, (and to a certain extent
inlet air temp) what should I have more of to make the best power?
Excellent question. I don't know. I suspect that boost is worth more than spark advance, with
mixture ratio somewhere in the middle. If I had a PMS, a datalogger, and a dyno, I think I'd
set spark advance to about 2/3 of the possible range the computer provides, set the mixture a
little on the lean side, and then run the boost up to the detonation point, and back off a
little. Then I'd play with the mixture to see if I can get more power, or get the motor to
stand more boost. Once I've got a good WOT boost level and mixture ratio, then we see how much
more advance it can take. Maybe.
Note that we haven't taken inlet air temp or density into account here, nor have we allowed for
real-world factors like: how fast can the wastegate react to boost spikes? This is just an
educated guess. Bottom line? Lots of testing. Lots. And you can't get the inlet air temp too
cold.
I don't have a knock problem. I'm just learning before it becomes an issue. Air temp and density aren't really serious factors for me at present because I'm using a MAP sensor and I'm not knocking, but I figure it's best to ask before I need to ask. Still struggling to find the time to revise my maps and iron out some minor inconveniences like engine startup, some idle fluxuation and fuel when approaching positive pressure. At the same time I'm going to be redoing all my vac/coolant lines in the near future to eliminate the possibility of them leaking, and I'm awaiting my Defi Link system from Gruppe-S (apparently white faced 52mm gauges aren't usually in stock so they had to special order them for me) so that I can monitor fuel pressure and get more precise EGT and boost/vac readings. I think my boost gauge is reading slightly low and my EGT probe placement makes it useful only as a reference point for change.
I have a GReddy Profec B Spec II installed but not operational at the moment (I lost my booklet), but the Turbonetics wastegate I have is known to be problematic, so how it's behaving is a variable that I can't presently account for.
I keep feeling like I'm hogging this thread with my own questions, but hopefully other people will learn and benefit from them as well. I've been a gineau pig thus far, why stop now? Anyway, I appreciate the help as always, Mobius. Thanks.
I have a GReddy Profec B Spec II installed but not operational at the moment (I lost my booklet), but the Turbonetics wastegate I have is known to be problematic, so how it's behaving is a variable that I can't presently account for.
I keep feeling like I'm hogging this thread with my own questions, but hopefully other people will learn and benefit from them as well. I've been a gineau pig thus far, why stop now? Anyway, I appreciate the help as always, Mobius. Thanks.
Ah, resurrection.
So an update on my fuel situation. I had serious stutter at around 0psi when my FMU was kicking in. I should say "have" because it's happening presently as well.
So here's the scoop after a little data logging. My AFR was crazy lean (16.8:1) at certain points (low RPM's, in vac. not under boost)so I'm going to fix that as soon as I can.
The problem around 0psi seems to be quite the opposite of what I thought. I was thinking I wasn't getting enough fuel and I was running lean. Turns out I'm running 8.2:1 AFR as the FMU kicks in. Under boost my AFR varies from around 11.2:1-12.9:1 (where it should be according to my map). When I get my new injectors and my defi-link gauges I'm going to test out my fuel pressure and whatnot, see how high it's getting, and then lean out my fuel map in that area. Still hitting 17.6:1 AFR at 5+psi and max bits on the fuel map with 650% boost correction...still gotta figure that one out.
Just thought I'd give an update since pretty much everything I've posted here has been regarding my gineau pig...I mean car.
So an update on my fuel situation. I had serious stutter at around 0psi when my FMU was kicking in. I should say "have" because it's happening presently as well.
So here's the scoop after a little data logging. My AFR was crazy lean (16.8:1) at certain points (low RPM's, in vac. not under boost)so I'm going to fix that as soon as I can.
The problem around 0psi seems to be quite the opposite of what I thought. I was thinking I wasn't getting enough fuel and I was running lean. Turns out I'm running 8.2:1 AFR as the FMU kicks in. Under boost my AFR varies from around 11.2:1-12.9:1 (where it should be according to my map). When I get my new injectors and my defi-link gauges I'm going to test out my fuel pressure and whatnot, see how high it's getting, and then lean out my fuel map in that area. Still hitting 17.6:1 AFR at 5+psi and max bits on the fuel map with 650% boost correction...still gotta figure that one out.
Just thought I'd give an update since pretty much everything I've posted here has been regarding my gineau pig...I mean car.
Last edited by HobieKopek; Nov 19, 2003 at 12:35 PM.
so you've maxed out the fuel map for 5 psi and above yet you are still running a 17:1 ish fuel mix? damn.. that's flippin lean for that much boost. Definitely will be curious to see what your fuel pressure come out at once you get those logged. the injectors are plenty plenty big for what you have...
I hate to suggest this... but it is one way around the problem... and I've seen it done. Get a new manifold with a second fuel rail. Then you can set up programming to only engage that second fuel rail when things go lean. That way you can overcompnesate while keeping fuel pressures low and make life a little bit easier. It's a bit of a costly add though, and I don't know the programming necessities off hand... but just a suggestion of course
Later.
Steve
I hate to suggest this... but it is one way around the problem... and I've seen it done. Get a new manifold with a second fuel rail. Then you can set up programming to only engage that second fuel rail when things go lean. That way you can overcompnesate while keeping fuel pressures low and make life a little bit easier. It's a bit of a costly add though, and I don't know the programming necessities off hand... but just a suggestion of course

Later.
Steve



