awd vs fwd driving technique
#1
Newbie
Thread Starter
Join Date: Mar 2003
Location: Wisconsin
Posts: 18
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
awd vs fwd driving technique
hi all,
my name is doug and i just purchased a new silver evo VIII a couple days ago.
i have extensive experience autocrossing a 200 hp civic hatch, doing lapping days, and also several years experience racing rwd shifter carts.
i do not however have any experience with an awd car.
since i am still in the break-in period and taking it pretty easy i don't have a real feel for how the car will handle at the limit.
is an awd car able to pull itself out of an oversteer situation with throttle application like a fwd - or will throttle application during oversteer simply amplify the oversteer (power slide)?
any thoughts on awd technique from REAL racers would be appreciated. please feel free to be as technical as necessary as far as racing terminology.
thanks,
-d
my name is doug and i just purchased a new silver evo VIII a couple days ago.
i have extensive experience autocrossing a 200 hp civic hatch, doing lapping days, and also several years experience racing rwd shifter carts.
i do not however have any experience with an awd car.
since i am still in the break-in period and taking it pretty easy i don't have a real feel for how the car will handle at the limit.
is an awd car able to pull itself out of an oversteer situation with throttle application like a fwd - or will throttle application during oversteer simply amplify the oversteer (power slide)?
any thoughts on awd technique from REAL racers would be appreciated. please feel free to be as technical as necessary as far as racing terminology.
thanks,
-d
#2
Evolving Member
Join Date: Dec 2005
Location: Bucks County PA
Posts: 128
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by laxEVO
hi all,
my name is doug and i just purchased a new silver evo VIII a couple days ago.
i have extensive experience autocrossing a 200 hp civic hatch, doing lapping days, and also several years experience racing rwd shifter carts.
i do not however have any experience with an awd car.
since i am still in the break-in period and taking it pretty easy i don't have a real feel for how the car will handle at the limit.
is an awd car able to pull itself out of an oversteer situation with throttle application like a fwd - or will throttle application during oversteer simply amplify the oversteer (power slide)?
any thoughts on awd technique from REAL racers would be appreciated. please feel free to be as technical as necessary as far as racing terminology.
thanks,
-d
my name is doug and i just purchased a new silver evo VIII a couple days ago.
i have extensive experience autocrossing a 200 hp civic hatch, doing lapping days, and also several years experience racing rwd shifter carts.
i do not however have any experience with an awd car.
since i am still in the break-in period and taking it pretty easy i don't have a real feel for how the car will handle at the limit.
is an awd car able to pull itself out of an oversteer situation with throttle application like a fwd - or will throttle application during oversteer simply amplify the oversteer (power slide)?
any thoughts on awd technique from REAL racers would be appreciated. please feel free to be as technical as necessary as far as racing terminology.
thanks,
-d
Sorry for digging up old threads but thats what happens when you "search"
Anyone??
#3
EvoM Guru
iTrader: (1)
Join Date: Dec 2002
Location: Boulder, Co.
Posts: 1,767
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by laxEVO
hi all,
my name is doug and i just purchased a new silver evo VIII a couple days ago.
i have extensive experience autocrossing a 200 hp civic hatch, doing lapping days, and also several years experience racing rwd shifter carts.
i do not however have any experience with an awd car.
since i am still in the break-in period and taking it pretty easy i don't have a real feel for how the car will handle at the limit.
is an awd car able to pull itself out of an oversteer situation with throttle application like a fwd - or will throttle application during oversteer simply amplify the oversteer (power slide)?
any thoughts on awd technique from REAL racers would be appreciated. please feel free to be as technical as necessary as far as racing terminology.
thanks,
-d
my name is doug and i just purchased a new silver evo VIII a couple days ago.
i have extensive experience autocrossing a 200 hp civic hatch, doing lapping days, and also several years experience racing rwd shifter carts.
i do not however have any experience with an awd car.
since i am still in the break-in period and taking it pretty easy i don't have a real feel for how the car will handle at the limit.
is an awd car able to pull itself out of an oversteer situation with throttle application like a fwd - or will throttle application during oversteer simply amplify the oversteer (power slide)?
any thoughts on awd technique from REAL racers would be appreciated. please feel free to be as technical as necessary as far as racing terminology.
thanks,
-d
EDIT: underlined above
Last edited by chronohunter; Feb 6, 2006 at 08:39 AM.
#4
Evolved Member
iTrader: (31)
Short answer, yes ... but is a little more complicated as Chronohunter has said ... if you are too far into the slide you can pull out by hitting the throttle but if you are just starting, you can avoid it by lifting on the throttle a little ... its hard to explain you just start to intuitively feel this after driving the EVO for a while ...
#5
hi!
congrats on your new car purchase! great choice!!!!
i can add the following:
its the "easiest" car to drive quickly that i have ever driven on the track; i have a bit of experience (i instruct for most of the groups around here, and race with NASA, EMRA, VSCCA, etc). been doing track stuff for over 10 years....
currently, i track an H1 honda civic, a PS-1 Ford Probe (PT-E now), and a vintage Lotus Super Seven. some of my previous track cars have been a 96 Mustang Cobra, a 95 GTI VR6, and a 91 Miata. i've driven many different Porsches on track, a 383 supercharged Firehawk, a Peter Farrell RX-7, a vortech blown SHO, all the BMW M3 variants, a BMW 540i Sport, a Nascar motored Datsun Scarab, a 1000 cc Diasio, and a bunch more that i am forgetting right now....
the EVO, even in totally stock form, is so easy to drive around a track; it is simply a very very "friendly" track car; the balance is very good, the combination of AWD, really good suspension, great brakes, and good power make the car really fun and nice to drive.... you can surgically carve up the track, easily hitting all your brake, turn-in, apex, and track-out points; this car will make even a so-so driver look and feel better than he might really be!
for comparison, my H1 FWD car has stiff springs and a big rear bar (and no front bar) in an attempt to "neutralize" it a bit. the general effect is that if you lift even a bit on corner entry, the rear will step out quickly -- then the driver must be ready with steering and throttle input to catch it and point it in the direction he wishes to go. understeer is still a dominant characteristic in the slower, sharper turns if too much power is applied..... don't get me wrong, this car is fun to race, but not really "friendly" and definitely not "easy".
the other end of the spectrum of my other personal cars would have been my Mustang Cobra. i took that to the track a few times when i was instructing, just to kinda "exercise" it a bit... it was stock powertrain wise, with the only mods being SVO springs and Illumina shocks. it was my DD at that time. that car was a case of mega understeer entering corners (both fast and slow); then it would bite and if you wanted, you could provoke it into a lurid, oversteering powerslide by slamming the throttle to the wood; really really fun, "hooligan-ness" kinda driving. it was fun, and felt fast, but in reality, lap times were much slower. i really did enjoy driving it like that, but it was really hard on the tires, and basically burned out the stock rear diff lsd clutch plates in two weekends (no more lsd ).
i ended up trading in the Cobra for the 2003 EVO (currently my daily driver); after test driving the EVO, there wasn't even a second thought! thats how good the EVO is!!!!
enjoy yours; i am sure that you will be spending quite a few exciting weekends at the track with it!
todd
PS when mine hits 100k miles (its at 33k now) it will be getting a full cage and will become one of my primary racecars.... hehehehheh.....
congrats on your new car purchase! great choice!!!!
i can add the following:
its the "easiest" car to drive quickly that i have ever driven on the track; i have a bit of experience (i instruct for most of the groups around here, and race with NASA, EMRA, VSCCA, etc). been doing track stuff for over 10 years....
currently, i track an H1 honda civic, a PS-1 Ford Probe (PT-E now), and a vintage Lotus Super Seven. some of my previous track cars have been a 96 Mustang Cobra, a 95 GTI VR6, and a 91 Miata. i've driven many different Porsches on track, a 383 supercharged Firehawk, a Peter Farrell RX-7, a vortech blown SHO, all the BMW M3 variants, a BMW 540i Sport, a Nascar motored Datsun Scarab, a 1000 cc Diasio, and a bunch more that i am forgetting right now....
the EVO, even in totally stock form, is so easy to drive around a track; it is simply a very very "friendly" track car; the balance is very good, the combination of AWD, really good suspension, great brakes, and good power make the car really fun and nice to drive.... you can surgically carve up the track, easily hitting all your brake, turn-in, apex, and track-out points; this car will make even a so-so driver look and feel better than he might really be!
for comparison, my H1 FWD car has stiff springs and a big rear bar (and no front bar) in an attempt to "neutralize" it a bit. the general effect is that if you lift even a bit on corner entry, the rear will step out quickly -- then the driver must be ready with steering and throttle input to catch it and point it in the direction he wishes to go. understeer is still a dominant characteristic in the slower, sharper turns if too much power is applied..... don't get me wrong, this car is fun to race, but not really "friendly" and definitely not "easy".
the other end of the spectrum of my other personal cars would have been my Mustang Cobra. i took that to the track a few times when i was instructing, just to kinda "exercise" it a bit... it was stock powertrain wise, with the only mods being SVO springs and Illumina shocks. it was my DD at that time. that car was a case of mega understeer entering corners (both fast and slow); then it would bite and if you wanted, you could provoke it into a lurid, oversteering powerslide by slamming the throttle to the wood; really really fun, "hooligan-ness" kinda driving. it was fun, and felt fast, but in reality, lap times were much slower. i really did enjoy driving it like that, but it was really hard on the tires, and basically burned out the stock rear diff lsd clutch plates in two weekends (no more lsd ).
i ended up trading in the Cobra for the 2003 EVO (currently my daily driver); after test driving the EVO, there wasn't even a second thought! thats how good the EVO is!!!!
enjoy yours; i am sure that you will be spending quite a few exciting weekends at the track with it!
todd
PS when mine hits 100k miles (its at 33k now) it will be getting a full cage and will become one of my primary racecars.... hehehehheh.....
#6
Evolving Member
Join Date: Dec 2005
Location: Bucks County PA
Posts: 128
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Thanks guys for your feedback.. I know I pulled this one out and dusted it off but your feedback really helps.. I guess my main concern is about this car being tail happy and correcting.. I do not want what happened to a WRX on one of my track days to happen to me..
#7
I would agree with what the guys are saying about balance, and the fact that you can power out of a turn much earlier than in a rwd car. You can really hammer the gas with the wheel cocked as you start to unwind it. Do that in a rwd car and you will swap ends for sure. I've never driven a fwd car on a racetrack, so I can't help you there.
Trending Topics
#8
EvoM Guru
iTrader: (1)
Join Date: Dec 2002
Location: Boulder, Co.
Posts: 1,767
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by Cloud_IX
Thanks guys for your feedback.. I know I pulled this one out and dusted it off but your feedback really helps.. I guess my main concern is about this car being tail happy and correcting.. I do not want what happened to a WRX on one of my track days to happen to me..
The concept of track days that creep peoples speed up without skid training is a recipe for eventual disaster...
#10
Evolved Member
iTrader: (1)
Originally Posted by Cloud_IX
I guess my main concern is about this car being tail happy and correcting.
So I wouldn't worry about the Evo being too "tail happy."
Emre
#11
EvoM Guru
iTrader: (1)
Join Date: Dec 2002
Location: Boulder, Co.
Posts: 1,767
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by kevo
I've seen way more ugly accident by pro drivers.....**** just happens.
#12
Evolved Member
iTrader: (18)
I can't speak for eveyone here but specifically my car looses the rear whenever driven hard or in rain. You should not get to that extreme in a daily basis unless your tires are near bold and/or you put serious power/torque.
I find easy to correct the car whenever I lose control from the back more over I want to reiterate that I only loose traction whenever mywheels are turned and I am full throtle.
The main difference on your FWD car is that when you loose traction the FWD always has a tendency to make turns wider because you are asking the front wheels to not only steer but also trasmit the power to the ground.
It is paramount to have a lowering stiff suspension on a FWD car in order to get maximum traction.
I find easy to correct the car whenever I lose control from the back more over I want to reiterate that I only loose traction whenever mywheels are turned and I am full throtle.
The main difference on your FWD car is that when you loose traction the FWD always has a tendency to make turns wider because you are asking the front wheels to not only steer but also trasmit the power to the ground.
It is paramount to have a lowering stiff suspension on a FWD car in order to get maximum traction.
#14
Evolved Member
iTrader: (18)
Originally Posted by Kayaalp
Far from it. A Porsche 930 is tail happy. An E46 M3 with traction control switched off is tail happy. The dominant cornering attitude of a stock Evo is understeer. And the WRX is even worse.
So I wouldn't worry about the Evo being too "tail happy."
Emre
So I wouldn't worry about the Evo being too "tail happy."
Emre
The Porsche has more weight in the back and much wider track. The power curve of the Porsche is completly anti bruning tires, it is very lineal until it gets to 4000rpm were the sound and the torque gets up again. By the way, the 930 are hard to find, very rare and old as hell
my .2c
#15
Evolved Member
iTrader: (1)
Originally Posted by fromWRXtoEVO
I think the Porsche has much better traction than the BMW M3, I am not saying this just because, I had a 911 Carrera(964) and my brother has a 02 M3 and have had a 97 and a 98 M3 with Dinan Supercharger. The BMW looses it easily.
Incidentally, did you ever drive the 964 on the track? Ever lift in a corner? That car has one of the most playful rear-ends I've ever experienced. Much more so than a stock Evo.
Originally Posted by fromWRXtoEVO
By the way, the 930 are hard to find, very rare and old as hell.
Emre