Advice on Test Pipe
This post shows a difference of a lowly 9hp 3lb/ft for a test pipe over the stock cat
https://www.evolutionm.net/forums/sh...12&postcount=7 (you have to look at post 8 for the comparison.)
https://www.evolutionm.net/forums/sh...ad.php?t=37340
There is a post comparing the randomtech to stock and testpipe. Guess what, stock did lose 10hp. The peak loss from the randomtech was 3hp, and it actually crosses above the testpipe chart in a few places showing that most of the variation here is just normal variation. Is not being able to breathe really worth a max of 2hp to you?!
There is also a member on the board who is selling 100cell cats that he is fabbing up for fitment (here). He claims these will flow 600cfm where the randomtech flows 400ish. Cobb is holding back on their cell counts, but I would guess they are less than 300.
On that note, if you still want to be lame, the RTP I just took off after 3k miles is for sale...
https://www.evolutionm.net/forums/sh...12&postcount=7 (you have to look at post 8 for the comparison.)
https://www.evolutionm.net/forums/sh...ad.php?t=37340
There is a post comparing the randomtech to stock and testpipe. Guess what, stock did lose 10hp. The peak loss from the randomtech was 3hp, and it actually crosses above the testpipe chart in a few places showing that most of the variation here is just normal variation. Is not being able to breathe really worth a max of 2hp to you?!
There is also a member on the board who is selling 100cell cats that he is fabbing up for fitment (here). He claims these will flow 600cfm where the randomtech flows 400ish. Cobb is holding back on their cell counts, but I would guess they are less than 300.
On that note, if you still want to be lame, the RTP I just took off after 3k miles is for sale...
Last edited by fostytou; Jan 31, 2008 at 09:41 AM.
You said "properly fitted" - umm ok so it fits... if it didnt, it wouldnt be on the car
You said "functioning cat" - that does not say high flow cat. Stock cats function too.
Go for the bigger pipe, but I recommend going green and getting a 3" cat. Seriously, comparatively there is almost no loss in power, and its horribly irresponsible to run catless off the track.
You *MIGHT* see a 5-10 hp gain from a clogged stock cat. You *MIGHT* see a 2-3hp difference between a test pipe and a high flow cat on a sub 400hp car. That 2-3hp difference will most likely be a simple variation from run to run, and not actual loss from the cat.
https://www.evolutionm.net/forums/sh...d.php?t=319046
You *MIGHT* see a 5-10 hp gain from a clogged stock cat. You *MIGHT* see a 2-3hp difference between a test pipe and a high flow cat on a sub 400hp car. That 2-3hp difference will most likely be a simple variation from run to run, and not actual loss from the cat.
https://www.evolutionm.net/forums/sh...d.php?t=319046
Again, if its a daily driver I don't recommend this but just my experience.
oh, and properly fitted means to the engine... i.e. not too small and not too large. get it now?
Im not recomending running without a cat on the road...........but from my first hand experience you are wrong. I have a Buschur 3" tb and with cams and a br highflow cat (brand new) I ran 318whp with a Dynoflash dyno tune. Two weeks later I swapped to a straight pipe, nothing else changed, and on the same dyno ran 331whp. I wish I could find the dyno charts....but that was two years ago. Anyway it does make a difference even with lower hp evos.
Again, if its a daily driver I don't recommend this but just my experience.
Again, if its a daily driver I don't recommend this but just my experience.
While I appreciate that input 2 weeks allows for quite a few factors to change. In the end, I posted back to back dynos that show little to no difference. I believe derekste mentioned in another thread that he also had little to no difference in back to back dyno runs with an open downpipe on his DSM to a catted system with the AMS cat, back to back.
I'm not sure what buschur uses for their cats, but there are multiple cases of back to back tests where proper 300 cell or less metal substrate cats were used and showed little to no difference in power.
Please, I'm all about making the power on the track, but for daily driving are you going to notice the 2hp? Please hear us out. I'm just trying to say that I have to breathe this air too, eat these crops that are yielding less too, sweat this summer heat that is hotter too, and worry about a polar ice cap that will be completely melted come summer 2013.
Last edited by fostytou; Jan 31, 2008 at 01:33 PM.
Honestly, I think that if you are going to have your 2yr old in the back seat you should have a cat on the car. Those fumes are definetly worse back there.
You don't want him/her breathing that crap in!
You don't want him/her breathing that crap in!
2. Thats on a CIVIC that is NA with 150hp, NOT TURBOED like an evo is....comprende?
3. It has been proven time and time again that a testpipe will yield ATLEAST 10-15WHP on a typical bolt on Evo or even stock.
Just to prove I went from a 3in Works HFC and slapped on a Megan resonated testpipe and gained 14whp. Mods are in my sig.
If you don't believe it maybe you should buy an evo first instead of arguing about something you obviously have no clue about. Why does anybody have to show dynographs to prove to you what everybody else already knows. Since you have a whole 9 posts click on that big search button and find out about the 100000000 posts that prove the testpipe gains.
Last edited by dbsears; Jan 31, 2008 at 06:03 PM.
If you don't believe it maybe you should buy an evo first instead of arguing about something you obviously have no clue about. Why does anybody have to show dynographs to prove to you what everybody else already knows. Since you have a whole 9 posts click on that big search button and find out about the 100000000 posts that prove the testpipe gains.
Why do people have to show dynographs? Because until you show some fact, you are just speculating. Both Frost and I have posted facts in support of our argument, and nobody from the "other side" has been kind enough to return the favor. The point is that until you start posting substantiating facts, you're only ranting.
when upgrading exhaust you need to start from the farthest point from the motor. catback, test pipe, downpipe, o2 housing, manifold. you can upgrade it however you want but thats the best order to go in. thats how i upgraded mine.
Thank you for that false information
Buschur and I believe Dynoflash did back to back tests with and without a cat on a bolt-on EVO and lost significant power. A test pipe on a mildly modded EVO will gain 10-15hp over a cat. It's not speculation. I dont know where you just made up that crap you just said, but wow. Completely false.
Buschur and I believe Dynoflash did back to back tests with and without a cat on a bolt-on EVO and lost significant power. A test pipe on a mildly modded EVO will gain 10-15hp over a cat. It's not speculation. I dont know where you just made up that crap you just said, but wow. Completely false.
Why do people have to show dynographs? Because until you show some fact, you are just speculating. Both Frost and I have posted facts in support of our argument, and nobody from the "other side" has been kind enough to return the favor. The point is that until you start posting substantiating facts, you're only ranting.
Last edited by dbsears; Jan 31, 2008 at 09:29 PM.


