ashinn90

Hey everyone,

So unfortunately I'm away from the Evo due to work, so I won't be able to post a video. But, has anyone else experienced a loud whine or howl that sounds like bad wind noise after a WOT pull in higher gears? It generally seems to happen in either 4th or 5th around 100+ mph. It also seems to happen under the previously mentioned situations and braking somewhat hard to bring speeds back down. I didn't experience any noises like this when I took the Evo on 1/4 mile runs at the track, but seems to happen when I'm on the freeway/highway intermittently.

I've brushed it off as bad wind noise due to what's probably terrible weatherseals on these cars, but I'm curious if anyone else has first-hand experience of this.

Thanks

Project_Broke

iTrader: (2)

Could just be drivetrain noise from slowing down faster than normal.

Could be tires.

I'm usually too focused to notice noises coming down from that speed, but mine does make a whine on decel.

Bee-Raddd

Highly likely to be crap/cheap tires.

They generally make a howling kinda noise at high speed. especially if they are directional tires.

If its more of a mechanical sound then it could be a diff or transfer case. Might pay to check oil levels and service them.

ashinn90

I know what you're saying about focusing, but that's interesting that you say you have a whine on decel. Does it happen all the time or is it intermittent?

ashinn90

Now I've heard a rumor that tires from Costco, regardless of the brand are cheaper in quality, but I haven't seemingly had any issues with them. I have Michelin Pilot Sport A/S 3+ at the stock wheel size on stock BBS's. And as Project_Broke mentioned, it generally happens when I brake hard and decel. Not necessarily a constant noise like tire noises.

Project_Broke

iTrader: (2)

Any time I'm running higher than 70 or so on Decel, it's most likely the rear diff.

I don't notice it anymore as I toasted my T-case on a drag launch and I hear that now

Evo9_Dubai

Are you sure it is not from the driver side mirror? First time I heard it, it scared the crap out of me but little research on evom showed that the driver side mirror made some terrible wind noise at high speed and goes away as you slow down.

CaptainSquirts

iTrader: (3)

I'll call bull on Costco using cheaper quality stuff. Would be odd for Michellin and Bridgestone(tires costco sells) to use different methods and material just for Costco. Sounds very expensive and pointless for them to do that than just use what they normally use/do... If anything Costco usually has the best stuff!

Sharkbite2000

iTrader: (21)

Just an evo always making all kind of noises

Project_Broke

iTrader: (2)

Working in the car business, I can tell you our tires are different entirely from off the shelf tires by the same manufacturer and series, due to manufacturer expectations.

So it is not off the wall that they would have cheaper materials, just as we have more expensive ones.

FWIW I'm not arguing they ARE, I'm just arguing it's not impossible.

CaptainSquirts

iTrader: (3)

So you're saying (sing the Costco one since it was mentioned) that a Pilot Super Sport tire from Tirerack can be different from Costco's? I would assume there would be a different "parts/serial number" for it if that was the case. I know there are different types of the same tires like Kumho v720 and Kumho v720 ACR(one viper uses). Also Pilot Super sport tires for regular and one for Buggati's that run for like 25k for the set are different from each other. But if stores sold the same tire without mentioning or noting anywhere it's different compared to the "regular" stuff, I can only imagine that's a big no no. But again I have no idea, just more of speaking my opinion.

Project_Broke

iTrader: (2)

Yep, usually the part number differs, but the exact same model name is on the tire. The tires differ in belt and rubber compounds. We run into issues because people buy a tire somewhere else when one blows, and then the TPMS won't recognize it because it's ever so slightly different. You have to find the part number on the tire to tell the difference. Treads are even the same.

Like I said, no idea if Cosco or anyone but OEMs engage in this practice, but it exists.

Edit: To address your other question; We do advertise that our OE tires are different, even though the models are the same, and offer explanations for the price difference. I may have a brochure somewhere I can quote.

Project_Broke

iTrader: (2)

It's the same practice several electronics and clothing manufacturers take part in.

The same TV's are that much cheaper somewhere else, because they are made cheaper.

The "outlet" clothing stores use cheaper materials on purpose.

ashinn90

Hmm i guess it could be that? I wasn't aware of this. . .I'll have to do a search. . .

And Sharkbite2000, you're right though lol

Stark_Tech

One thing you could try is to find a set of tires from another evo or similar that you can borrow and throw them on! Go see if it still does it with an entirely different set of tires. This is assuming you live near someone with the right wheels and tires you need to do this. I have several friends with evo's so this would be easy for me. Wish I could help you more.