I've had great results with my Michelin Pilot Alpin PA2 winter performance tires for over 20k miles since last winter going into this upcoming winter. I'd get a new set of PA4's in a heartbeat.

 

Unless you are planning to run all season tires year round, then I would get snow tires. No sense in using all weather just for the winter in my opinion.

I found fantastic performance with Hankook icept evo snow tires. The car handles like a beast with these in the snow. I live in northern NY and see plenty of snow.

Best of luck,
Kevin

 

I had a set of Dunlop SP Winter Sports on my 9 (when I had it) and they were a solid winter tire. They are pretty responsive for a snow tire and never had an issue with them lacking traction in dry conditions or in any type of snow. I'm from Western NY (think 7' of snow in buffalo) and live in the Boston Area. Snow is my thing...

But as everyone else says... Get a pair of winter tires... Any winter tires, and you'll pretty much be golden