im in the same situation. drove the 335i a few months back and wasnt impressed. drove a 135 recently and i really like it a lot... but enough to get rid of my evo? i cant decide.. the idea of starting fresh with a 3yr newer car is apealing, but i love my evo.

 

same boat as the OP...I loved the driving experience of the 1, but I was 50/50 on the looks and the backseat is a joke, not to mention the leasing cost of the 1 is outrageous...I love the styling of the 335 and it is def a quick car for stock...so i ordered one in auto.

the power on my evo is (was) addicting as hell, but i wanted to have just one car that I could DD and was still fun, unlike my jeep liberty which isn't fun at all and drinks gas like it's going outta style.