Last week we had an argument in my group about who's wife made the best cookie.

Today we had a bake off!

 

lol..looks good! i can do the judging

 

I would like the sample one of each please! Which did your wife make and who won?

 

1: healthy (113 cal each) peanut butter cholocate chip oatmeal
2. chocolate chip
3. chocolate chip peanut butter chip
4. chocolate chip, oatmeal, pecan, white chocolate chip
5. oatmeal chocolate chip

The voting was 2, 4, 3, 1, 5

Amy made #1. They are more like cake/muffins than cookies though.

 

That's awesome!

The guys I work with (in IT) all cook, I should arrange something like this between us.

 

#1 and #4 would be disqualified due to not making the individual cookies big enough. When I make cookies I make them the size of a hamburger (that's my guide). That way I don't feel like a fat *** and grab 4-5 little **** ant cookies. I grab one man sized cookie, eat it, feel good, and can honestly say "I only had one".

 

OK guys, I got a sample of each cookie from Sean so stay tuned for my review

 

1. Soft and moist, definitely good for a "healthy" cookie.
2. Awesome! Can never go wrong with a good choc chip cookie.
3. Nice BIG size and plenty soft/moist.
4. Very soft with a nice array of flavors. Possibly a little too sweet though.
5. A decent cookie, but it leaves my wanting raisins.

The winner is #2! Thanks Sean!

P.S. I feel kind of sick after wolfing down all those cookies.

 

shouldve had a beer with them

 

Just ate another #1 attempting to soak up some of last night's beer

 

You guys are cruel...I want a cookie now.

 

Ummmm gross!!!!!!!