6 Speed Tranny a weak link?
Originally Posted by Kee1pride
Guys. I need some help. My friend just pointed out to me that The oil mitsu sold me is for the transfer case, and that it should NOT be in my transmission. What is the part number to the 6 speed transmission fluid? Did a search but there were just way too many threads.
I went to mitsu about a month and a half ago and told them i needed to buy tranmission fluid for my 2005 Evo MR 6speed. They handed me over a tin that said LSD gear oil and I asked them, "are you sure this isn't for the differential?". They told me, "no, that's what goes in the transmission too".
It's been in my freshly rebuild TRE spec transmission a month now. I feel like I could go over there and just knock the guy out who sold it to me.
I've gone to the track 2 times and launched the car 8 times on this fluid. Are there any largely bad effects for having it in my transmission or what can happen? I will go to my dealership as soon as I get off work and explain what happened to the GM there.
I hope nothing bad happens to my car again
I went to mitsu about a month and a half ago and told them i needed to buy tranmission fluid for my 2005 Evo MR 6speed. They handed me over a tin that said LSD gear oil and I asked them, "are you sure this isn't for the differential?". They told me, "no, that's what goes in the transmission too".
It's been in my freshly rebuild TRE spec transmission a month now. I feel like I could go over there and just knock the guy out who sold it to me.
I've gone to the track 2 times and launched the car 8 times on this fluid. Are there any largely bad effects for having it in my transmission or what can happen? I will go to my dealership as soon as I get off work and explain what happened to the GM there.
I hope nothing bad happens to my car again

Kee1pride: Follow the link below
http://www.mitsubishiparts.net/catalog/?section=489
You want the 6 speed manual tranny fluid, part # MZ313376
Get the LSD gear out out of there asap, it will put extra strain on your sychros as it is a more viscous fluid.
Sooo EVIL
http://www.mitsubishiparts.net/catalog/?section=489
You want the 6 speed manual tranny fluid, part # MZ313376
Get the LSD gear out out of there asap, it will put extra strain on your sychros as it is a more viscous fluid.
Originally Posted by Ookami
Ahhhhh ! You've seen through my evil plan to buy up all the 6 speed transmissions people would sell !


Last edited by DaWorstPlaya; Nov 2, 2006 at 02:07 PM.
Originally Posted by sonicnofadz
Are you experiencing any problems with the tranny? You should not continue to drive the car until you have put the correct fluid in the tranny. If the transmission is damaged, have the dealership pay for it.
the first time my transmission broke i didn't even bother taking to them because i thought it was my fault and was going to take responsibility for my actions. so i sent it to TRE to be race built. well later i come to find out it's my mechanics fault and he installed my clutch in wrong and bent a passenger side axle seal. oil leaked out and it bbq'd it self. regardless the point is i didn't try and take it to mitsubishi and took the honest road. if it breaks this time, it's their damn fault and i will seek payment for it.
Originally Posted by DaWorstPlaya
Torque is what breaks parts and different gears being of different width can only hold a certain amount of torque before they fail. Therefore it is always a good idea to determine how much power a tranny can hold based on the weakest gear. The last time I spoke to Jon @ TRE, he mentioned that the 4th gear which was the weakest could only hold a dynamic torque rating of 380ft.lb after the stress testing he did. That means stay below 380ft.lb of torque at the crank and you should be fine. If you produce more than that, your 4th gear will give up. Now by comparison the 1st and 2nd gear for the 6 speed are almost indestructable because of their width (figuratively speaking).
How that converts to wheel torque is the hardest to figure out. To be on the safe side I always use a drivetrain loss of 25% (because of AWD) which gives us a wheel torque rating of 285ft.lb at the wheels. Some people use anywhere from 18%-25% ... I ususally tend to over estimate and be on the safe side. Using 18% drivetrain loss gives you 311ft.lb at the wheels. So the 6 speed can hold anywhere from 285-311 ft.lb of torque.
How that converts to wheel torque is the hardest to figure out. To be on the safe side I always use a drivetrain loss of 25% (because of AWD) which gives us a wheel torque rating of 285ft.lb at the wheels. Some people use anywhere from 18%-25% ... I ususally tend to over estimate and be on the safe side. Using 18% drivetrain loss gives you 311ft.lb at the wheels. So the 6 speed can hold anywhere from 285-311 ft.lb of torque.
The measured effective torque drops as gearing between the crank and the rear wheel rises (lowers numerically) and power is wasted through friction at each transfer of power between internal components. With the engine in first gear, more torque gets applied than it does in any higher gear. As gear ratios rise (drop numerically), the mechanical advantage of the engine (read: measured or effective torque) drops. And each successively higher gear will fall lower on the torque chart than the gear before it, as a result of gearing effect (mechanical advantage) and energy losses.
Thus, from an engineering standpoint, all gears do not see the same torque load (like, e.g., 380 ft/lbs at the crank). One must calculate the specific torque load an engine will create on a specific gear in order to determine its effective torque rating, and the engine would have to put out torque readings in excess of the specific gear's effective torque rating in that gear in order to have the potential of damaging the gear through torque alone.
Heat reduces the strength of the gears and makes it more plastic. Heat any gearset enough and you will have the potential to draw the temper from the metal (like annealing it in a heat treating context), and cause it to have lower strength characteristics. If you can remove excess heat from the transmission with a transmission fluid cooler and pump, you can keep the critical temperature lower and reduce the temperature effect on the gearset.
Jon (TRE) also has some other modifications that he does to the 6 speed transmissions with these issues in mind. I'll let him discuss them (or keep them to himself
) as he wishes. So, anyone broken a TRE modified 6 speed?
Bill Ziegler went through a few of them racing T2 Nationals before he and Jon decided that a 5-Speed swap was in order (and why not an IX motor while he's at it). Jon does magic with trannies, but there is only so much that can be done. Yes, Bill has a full tranny oil cooler setup and drives the **** outta the car.
I am aware of torque multiplication happening. It is the whole idea behind a transmission. But in 1st gear the highest amount of torque being applied is to the gear on the output shaft not the gear on the input shaft. Smaller gear on input shaft drives bigger gear on output shaft. Torque is mulitplied because for several revolution of the smaller gear, 1 revolution of the bigger gear occurs.
Torque = force at a 90 deg angle x radius
Now think of the input drive shaft a that contains a certain amount of rotational force on it. In 1st gear, the gears on the input shaft won't experience as much torque as the 1st gear on the output shaft. Why? because of the difference in radii. But as you go progressively higher through the gears the torque applied to the gears on the input shaft progressively rises because of increasing radii while the torque experienced by the gears in the output shaft progressively falls. IMHO you are partially correct. What I don't know is if it is the gear on the input shaft failing 1st or the gear on the output shaft. My suspicion in on the gear on the input shaft.
VR4orceCJ is correct, I spoke to Jon and he did mention that they had already tried shot-peening, cyrotreating and running an external cooler but still encountered transmission failures.
Torque = force at a 90 deg angle x radius
Now think of the input drive shaft a that contains a certain amount of rotational force on it. In 1st gear, the gears on the input shaft won't experience as much torque as the 1st gear on the output shaft. Why? because of the difference in radii. But as you go progressively higher through the gears the torque applied to the gears on the input shaft progressively rises because of increasing radii while the torque experienced by the gears in the output shaft progressively falls. IMHO you are partially correct. What I don't know is if it is the gear on the input shaft failing 1st or the gear on the output shaft. My suspicion in on the gear on the input shaft.
VR4orceCJ is correct, I spoke to Jon and he did mention that they had already tried shot-peening, cyrotreating and running an external cooler but still encountered transmission failures.
I'll share some of my findings.
5 speed rated working torque = 375ft.lbs
5 speed peak torque of simulated destructive load test = 900ft.lbs
6 speed rated working torque = 290fl.lbs
6 speed peak torque of simulated destructive load test = 700ft.lbs
Torque values are dynamic and approximate.
Choosing a clutch with an appropriate torque capacity for the application is wise. Ideally the clutch should hold 10-15% more torque than what the engine is capable of generating or half of burst torque.
WTZ never broke any gears in any of the transmission that we built for him but heat was an issue that never was fully resolved. I didn't see the oil cooler that he ended up using nor I am sure if the rules in T2 allow for a heat exchanger large enough to deal with the heat but a 20,000 BTU heat exchanger would not go unused if the 6 speed is to be tracked for extended periods of time.
Jon Ripple
www.teamrip.com
5 speed rated working torque = 375ft.lbs
5 speed peak torque of simulated destructive load test = 900ft.lbs
6 speed rated working torque = 290fl.lbs
6 speed peak torque of simulated destructive load test = 700ft.lbs
Torque values are dynamic and approximate.
Choosing a clutch with an appropriate torque capacity for the application is wise. Ideally the clutch should hold 10-15% more torque than what the engine is capable of generating or half of burst torque.
WTZ never broke any gears in any of the transmission that we built for him but heat was an issue that never was fully resolved. I didn't see the oil cooler that he ended up using nor I am sure if the rules in T2 allow for a heat exchanger large enough to deal with the heat but a 20,000 BTU heat exchanger would not go unused if the 6 speed is to be tracked for extended periods of time.
Jon Ripple
www.teamrip.com
For those of you who may not be acquainted with Jon Ripple, he is the owner of Team Rip Engineering, and the transmission builder/guru.
His answers above should be the definitive comment in this thread. Still no broken TRE modded 6 speeds identified.
His answers above should be the definitive comment in this thread. Still no broken TRE modded 6 speeds identified.
Originally Posted by DaWorstPlaya
I am aware of torque multiplication happening. It is the whole idea behind a transmission. But in 1st gear the highest amount of torque being applied is to the gear on the output shaft not the gear on the input shaft. Smaller gear on input shaft drives bigger gear on output shaft. Torque is mulitplied because for several revolution of the smaller gear, 1 revolution of the bigger gear occurs.
Torque = force at a 90 deg angle x radius
Now think of the input drive shaft a that contains a certain amount of rotational force on it. In 1st gear, the gears on the input shaft won't experience as much torque as the 1st gear on the output shaft. Why? because of the difference in radii. But as you go progressively higher through the gears the torque applied to the gears on the input shaft progressively rises because of increasing radii while the torque experienced by the gears in the output shaft progressively falls. IMHO you are partially correct. What I don't know is if it is the gear on the input shaft failing 1st or the gear on the output shaft. My suspicion in on the gear on the input shaft.
VR4orceCJ is correct, I spoke to Jon and he did mention that they had already tried shot-peening, cyrotreating and running an external cooler but still encountered transmission failures.
Torque = force at a 90 deg angle x radius
Now think of the input drive shaft a that contains a certain amount of rotational force on it. In 1st gear, the gears on the input shaft won't experience as much torque as the 1st gear on the output shaft. Why? because of the difference in radii. But as you go progressively higher through the gears the torque applied to the gears on the input shaft progressively rises because of increasing radii while the torque experienced by the gears in the output shaft progressively falls. IMHO you are partially correct. What I don't know is if it is the gear on the input shaft failing 1st or the gear on the output shaft. My suspicion in on the gear on the input shaft.
VR4orceCJ is correct, I spoke to Jon and he did mention that they had already tried shot-peening, cyrotreating and running an external cooler but still encountered transmission failures.
There is quite a bit happening when the transmission is loaded to the gills with torque, especially during a nasty clutch dump. Those peak torque numbers really push things around and usually not for the better. In general transmissions do not take gear & shaft deflection lightly and axial & radial thrust loads can easily exceed not only the limits of the bearings but their respective bores. Good thing those problems can be solved.
Jon@TRE
Originally Posted by Warrtalon
I thought they just said that Bill Zeigler's 6spds were built by Jon and still broke (just not the gears), right?
Originally Posted by GEARS
I'll share some of my findings.
5 speed rated working torque = 375ft.lbs
5 speed peak torque of simulated destructive load test = 900ft.lbs
6 speed rated working torque = 290fl.lbs
6 speed peak torque of simulated destructive load test = 700ft.lbs
Torque values are dynamic and approximate.
5 speed rated working torque = 375ft.lbs
5 speed peak torque of simulated destructive load test = 900ft.lbs
6 speed rated working torque = 290fl.lbs
6 speed peak torque of simulated destructive load test = 700ft.lbs
Torque values are dynamic and approximate.
Originally Posted by GEARS
WTZ never broke any gears in any of the transmission that we built for him but heat was an issue that never was fully resolved. I didn't see the oil cooler that he ended up using nor I am sure if the rules in T2 allow for a heat exchanger large enough to deal with the heat but a 20,000 BTU heat exchanger would not go unused if the 6 speed is to be tracked for extended periods of time.
This reminds me of a question I have been meaning to ask you. What temp should we be looking at before we need to start slowing down on track? What number should we really stay away from?
Using a greddy temp gauge with the probe installed by the shifter mech like where you installed mine.
Originally Posted by GEARS
I feel that proper shot peening will provide the longest service life but this is only 2nd to using a clutch with an appropriate torque capacity.
Jon@TRE
Jon@TRE






