View Poll Results: Did Mitsubishi screw up on the clutch?
Yes, You screwed the pooch



483
61.69%
No, The clutch is fine.



300
38.31%
Voters: 783. You may not vote on this poll
Did Mitsu screw up on the clutch
Originally posted by timzcat
Oh I forgot. ACTman the Service Manual says the pressure plate load is 2096. FYI...
Oh I forgot. ACTman the Service Manual says the pressure plate load is 2096. FYI...
The method we use measures peak load going both directions (compression and rebound) which actually measures load plus friction in one direction then load minus friction in the other direction. We average the two numbers so that friction cancels out and all you have left is true clamp load.
Some aftermarket clutch companies will measure only at the new installed position which only matters when the clutch is new. They might place their performance clutch directly on peak clamp load and then it wears goes down from that point forward. Compared the stock which actually gets stronger with wear first then falls off they might claim a 30% increase when really it's about 15% when you compare peak clamp load. The kicker is that the clutch doesn't last as long either.
Some companies claim all kinds of numbers but actaully don't do any clamp load measuring. These are really entertaining when you know what they actually produce. So there is a lot more to it than what one might think when it comes to clamp load.
To get away from measured clamp loads, we always publish a percentage of increase and estimated peak torque capacities. We also provide the math formula we use to calculate torque capacity right in our catalog.
Originally posted by SILVER SURFER
The only thing I can think of regarding this observation is that the STI has a 6 speed with shorter gearing and an engine with better low end torque. The STI does not need to load/slip the clutch as much to take off smoothly on the street, or launch in a drag race.
The problem is that the first gear is a bit to high for drag racing in this car, you have to rev so high and slip the clutch a lot to get a good launch. If you slip the clutch too much it over heats so that even when you let it out completely under full throttle it won't grab, and that's when you really smoke it. A clutch disk with a material that holds up better to heat might help the situation, as well as a more aggresive presure plate or twin disk unit.
The only thing I can think of regarding this observation is that the STI has a 6 speed with shorter gearing and an engine with better low end torque. The STI does not need to load/slip the clutch as much to take off smoothly on the street, or launch in a drag race.
The problem is that the first gear is a bit to high for drag racing in this car, you have to rev so high and slip the clutch a lot to get a good launch. If you slip the clutch too much it over heats so that even when you let it out completely under full throttle it won't grab, and that's when you really smoke it. A clutch disk with a material that holds up better to heat might help the situation, as well as a more aggresive presure plate or twin disk unit.
Materials: The material on the EVO disc is really good stuff and there is a lot of it compared to some cars. I cannot think of a good improvement in an organic material since you are basically at the mercy of the resin's melting point. Our performance organic might help a little but both materials have worked well for John Shepherd in his 9 sec. DSM and his clutch is much smaller.
Kevlar will wear slower but will hold less power and will heat the opposing surfaces prematurely since it doesn't conduct heat away from the surface.
A metallic will be too harsh for street IMO but may conduct a little more heat, depending on surface area.
A multidisc metallic will have even more trouble with warpage, wear, etc. if heat tolerance while slipped is the real issue. This is why you don't see race cars (Nascar, IRL, others) slip the clutch. It is better to just break the tires loose. On the EVO you don't have that luxury.
Carbon/carbon is more heat tolerant, but hell on the wallet and not really meant for the street.
From what I know so far, I think the EVO clutch failures are not from one single problem. We will see.
Originally posted by ACTman
That's interesting. I have never seen pressure plate loads in service manuals. There are different methods of measuring clamp load so you have to compare apples with apples.
The method we use measures peak load going both directions (compression and rebound) which actually measures load plus friction in one direction then load minus friction in the other direction. We average the two numbers so that friction cancels out and all you have left is true clamp load.
Some aftermarket clutch companies will measure only at the new installed position which only matters when the clutch is new. They might place their performance clutch directly on peak clamp load and then it wears goes down from that point forward. Compared the stock which actually gets stronger with wear first then falls off they might claim a 30% increase when really it's about 15% when you compare peak clamp load. The kicker is that the clutch doesn't last as long either.
Some companies claim all kinds of numbers but actaully don't do any clamp load measuring. These are really entertaining when you know what they actually produce. So there is a lot more to it than what one might think when it comes to clamp load.
To get away from measured clamp loads, we always publish a percentage of increase and estimated peak torque capacities. We also provide the math formula we use to calculate torque capacity right in our catalog.
That's interesting. I have never seen pressure plate loads in service manuals. There are different methods of measuring clamp load so you have to compare apples with apples.
The method we use measures peak load going both directions (compression and rebound) which actually measures load plus friction in one direction then load minus friction in the other direction. We average the two numbers so that friction cancels out and all you have left is true clamp load.
Some aftermarket clutch companies will measure only at the new installed position which only matters when the clutch is new. They might place their performance clutch directly on peak clamp load and then it wears goes down from that point forward. Compared the stock which actually gets stronger with wear first then falls off they might claim a 30% increase when really it's about 15% when you compare peak clamp load. The kicker is that the clutch doesn't last as long either.
Some companies claim all kinds of numbers but actaully don't do any clamp load measuring. These are really entertaining when you know what they actually produce. So there is a lot more to it than what one might think when it comes to clamp load.
To get away from measured clamp loads, we always publish a percentage of increase and estimated peak torque capacities. We also provide the math formula we use to calculate torque capacity right in our catalog.
There was a noticeable difference in feel once I adjusted the free play of the clutch, the pedal was a good 10mm lower then it should have been and therefore the travel distance was not within spec. Interesting to see if anyone else checks theirs to see if the are all like this. I could clearly see the pushrod was well threaded into the u-bracket that attaches to the pedal. It automatically seemed like it was in to far just looking at it.
After a good drive, I did crack the bleeder to check for pressure and only got normal flow, so the the master cylinder is reseating properly and not holding pressure in the line.
Hi all,
My EVO is in the shop now because the throwout bearing was bad. After mitsu pulled everything apart they decided that they needed to replace not only the throwout bearing but also the flywheel, and pressure plate(all defective from factory). I went ahead and replaced the clutch disk($111.00) myself to save labor costs later on. It was pretty worn already.
I now have 13,000mi on my EVO.
My EVO is in the shop now because the throwout bearing was bad. After mitsu pulled everything apart they decided that they needed to replace not only the throwout bearing but also the flywheel, and pressure plate(all defective from factory). I went ahead and replaced the clutch disk($111.00) myself to save labor costs later on. It was pretty worn already.
I now have 13,000mi on my EVO.
Dirk Starksen of ACT Inc seems to be the knowledgeable resource here. I don't know about everyone else but the rumors and hear say are getting real old. Let's see what ACT comes up with and go from there. I believe Mr. Starken knows more about clutches than anyone else here.
Originally posted by bpclements
So what symptoms would a bad throwout bearing show?
So what symptoms would a bad throwout bearing show?
Originally posted by kitra
Dirk Starksen of ACT Inc seems to be the knowledgeable resource here. I don't know about everyone else but the rumors and hear say are getting real old. Let's see what ACT comes up with and go from there. I believe Mr. Starken knows more about clutches than anyone else here.
Dirk Starksen of ACT Inc seems to be the knowledgeable resource here. I don't know about everyone else but the rumors and hear say are getting real old. Let's see what ACT comes up with and go from there. I believe Mr. Starken knows more about clutches than anyone else here.
Dirk Starksen of ACT Inc seems to be the knowledgeable resource here. I don't know about everyone else but the rumors and hear say are getting real old. Let's see what ACT comes up with and go from there. I believe Mr. Starken knows more about clutches than anyone else here.
Duh..
Everyone is just asking questions and discussing the topic, after all this is a forum. I don't know that it's rumors and here say. For the most part people are relaying thier experiences with the clutch to ACT to try and give them information from the users perspective, since they don't get to see all these cars directly.
Originally posted by ACTman
Noise that changes (gets better or worse) by slightly depressing the pedal. When it gets really bad sometimes you will get a vibrating pedal you can feel in your foot.
Noise that changes (gets better or worse) by slightly depressing the pedal. When it gets really bad sometimes you will get a vibrating pedal you can feel in your foot.
Once ACT gets a setup for the evo to market I'm going to petition Mitsubishi to check my throwout bearing and clutch assembly. If they won't do it I'll take it to a certified third party and have them do it and install an ACT setup while there at it. Then If the bearing turn out to be the source of the noise and or turns out to be bad I'll petition mitsu to reimburse me for the labor. Like they ever would....
Thanks again for your involvement ACTman.
Last edited by Mad_SB; Jul 22, 2003 at 01:37 PM.
Originally posted by mad_VIII
... he said it was because I was applying just enough pressure to unload the drive line and that was preventing the back faces of the gears from "being excited." BTW that is what mitsu contends the decel noise is, the back faces of the gears.
... he said it was because I was applying just enough pressure to unload the drive line and that was preventing the back faces of the gears from "being excited." BTW that is what mitsu contends the decel noise is, the back faces of the gears.
The engine's natural torsional vibration is what normally causes transmission decel noises. The possible reason that the noise goes away when you push on the pedal is that friction of the thrust of on the crank reduces the amount of vibration. Torsional vibration and disc dampener design are not subjects I want to try and explain in a forum like this because it gets really complicated. I do still have other work to do.
Darn,
So TOB and even a new clutch may not help with the decel noise?
Oh well, maybe I'll just live with it and go ahead with a power mod, heh. Definitely want to replace the clutch anyway if it starts to give me problems.
Thanks for the info.
FB
So TOB and even a new clutch may not help with the decel noise?
Oh well, maybe I'll just live with it and go ahead with a power mod, heh. Definitely want to replace the clutch anyway if it starts to give me problems.
Thanks for the info.
FB
I haven't noticed any odd decel noise coming from my car. I even heard a sound clip of someone having the decel noise. Guess it is the luck of the draw, lol. Maybe I just got lucky. I'll have to try to get it up on the board if anyone is interested.

