I'd get option one with 38k miles if the price is right.. That's pretty low mileage

 

Keep looking for a stock 9 with low kms

 

get the 05

 

I purchased my 8 after spending months looking for the right IX. Finally came down to a IX with 90k miles or an 8 for a grand more with 19k miles. I really wanted a 9 but picking up something with low miles was worth it to me.

I'd say either the 03 or 05. an Evo with 90k miles and too many unknowns sounds like a future headache to me.