V5, NLTS and the load threshold bug
Thread Starter
Joined: Feb 2007
Posts: 9,486
Likes: 67
From: Melbourne, Australia
Hey Guys,
As you know I implemented a load threshold for the downshift blippers that use NLTS. Basically some users said they hit 100% TPS when downshifting and could I implement a load threshold.
Well that was done - however it introduced a unique bug.
Basically when you shift with NTLS the load is say 200+, however whilst the shift is happening the load drops. This sometimes reduces the load below the threshold.
I need a couple of logs of people NLTS shifting and NLTS downshift blipping.
I need to see how the load behaves when doing the above so I can find a way to fix the bug
Cheers
D>
As you know I implemented a load threshold for the downshift blippers that use NLTS. Basically some users said they hit 100% TPS when downshifting and could I implement a load threshold.
Well that was done - however it introduced a unique bug.
Basically when you shift with NTLS the load is say 200+, however whilst the shift is happening the load drops. This sometimes reduces the load below the threshold.
I need a couple of logs of people NLTS shifting and NLTS downshift blipping.
I need to see how the load behaves when doing the above so I can find a way to fix the bug

Cheers
D>
Just set it so once the NLTS is engaged, it stays engaged until the TPS falls below the TPS setting. This would make adjusting the "NLTS load activation point" a useful tool again. If I set my load to 200 and TPS to 95%, if I NLTS shift and even slightly mess up my shift from one gear to the next, the load drops below the 200 mark and then I free-rev my engine.
Last edited by Jack_of_Trades; May 18, 2008 at 05:59 PM.
My issue is that when NLTS shifting with the load threshold set high (like 200), if you take too long to shift and the load drops below 200, you'll disengage the NLTS function and free-rev the engine and bounce off the rev limiter. This is why I set my NLTS load threshold to 100 right now to limit this from even happening again. Though this does make me vulnerable to activating NLTS by accident sometimes.
I would fix this by having it set so if you exceed the load threshold setting (200 or whatever) and NLTS is activated, it won't disengage until you go below the TPS setting (aka, let your foot off the gas). Basically making the load threshold only useful for activating NLTS, not deactivating it.
I would fix this by having it set so if you exceed the load threshold setting (200 or whatever) and NLTS is activated, it won't disengage until you go below the TPS setting (aka, let your foot off the gas). Basically making the load threshold only useful for activating NLTS, not deactivating it.
I was the person who asked tephra to include a load threshold for the NLTS as I was hitting it while down shifting. I tested it a lot and I have mine set to 160. I found that this load is never hit when down shifting, and even if you stay on the NLTS for too long you still will be above this load point.
I have been running the NLTS load threshold for many moths and have never encountered a single problem, it just takes some fine tunning of the value to prevent yourself from running into this "bug"
I have been running the NLTS load threshold for many moths and have never encountered a single problem, it just takes some fine tunning of the value to prevent yourself from running into this "bug"
Thread Starter
Joined: Feb 2007
Posts: 9,486
Likes: 67
From: Melbourne, Australia
Yup that's my intention. But I couldn't get my head around it.
That's a good idea Jamie - using the load as a NLTS enable parameter, but not a disable one.
Sometimes my brain can't think - been reading too much ASM methinks
That's a good idea Jamie - using the load as a NLTS enable parameter, but not a disable one.
Sometimes my brain can't think - been reading too much ASM methinks
Trending Topics
Thread Starter
Joined: Feb 2007
Posts: 9,486
Likes: 67
From: Melbourne, Australia
ok I have added some code in - so that:
1) when you first shift it records the load at that point in time
2) subsequently when it decides to enable the temporary revlimiter or not it uses that saved load as the decision against the load threshold.
3) when you finally release the clutch it forgets the saved load
so in normal acceleration:
loads will be above 200 when you shift, it will then save 200 and even if you drop to 150 (ie slow slow shifter) then it will still keep the false rev-limiter enabled.
so really all you need todo is set your load threshold below your minimum load for shifting, so probably around the 170 mark..
of course there will be situations where you may think NLTS should kick in but wont - ie shifts at a funny RPM without full boost..
1) when you first shift it records the load at that point in time
2) subsequently when it decides to enable the temporary revlimiter or not it uses that saved load as the decision against the load threshold.
3) when you finally release the clutch it forgets the saved load
so in normal acceleration:
loads will be above 200 when you shift, it will then save 200 and even if you drop to 150 (ie slow slow shifter) then it will still keep the false rev-limiter enabled.
so really all you need todo is set your load threshold below your minimum load for shifting, so probably around the 170 mark..
of course there will be situations where you may think NLTS should kick in but wont - ie shifts at a funny RPM without full boost..
Awesome work tephra, and exactly what I was thinking Jack!
Aiming for this to be in V6?
Either way I can grab a couple of logs for your if you give me a better idea of what you are looking for... do you just want me to log 2 byte load, rpm and tps and do a couple of downshift blips? ...if you want a really hardcore log I can log a session when I'm at autobahn in 3 weeks also, but there is obviously a short wait for that...
Aiming for this to be in V6?
Either way I can grab a couple of logs for your if you give me a better idea of what you are looking for... do you just want me to log 2 byte load, rpm and tps and do a couple of downshift blips? ...if you want a really hardcore log I can log a session when I'm at autobahn in 3 weeks also, but there is obviously a short wait for that...
Thread Starter
Joined: Feb 2007
Posts: 9,486
Likes: 67
From: Melbourne, Australia
I need a tester for this - someone that understands the bug and can test to see if it still exists.
Obvious choice would be Dudical26, but I am not sure if he is near an Evo atm
Please post your ROMID when/if you volunteer
Obvious choice would be Dudical26, but I am not sure if he is near an Evo atm

Please post your ROMID when/if you volunteer



