really bad knock all of a sudden
Thread Starter
Joined: Feb 2007
Posts: 9,486
Likes: 67
From: Melbourne, Australia
no knock.
BUT
1) I havn't done conclusive testing for fear of blowing something
2) I have changed the tune significantly
3) I have had a service ie oil change...
4) I am working on a MIVEC theory which may be the root cause, and coupled with #3 might be a significant discovery
BUT
1) I havn't done conclusive testing for fear of blowing something
2) I have changed the tune significantly
3) I have had a service ie oil change...
4) I am working on a MIVEC theory which may be the root cause, and coupled with #3 might be a significant discovery
Thread Starter
Joined: Feb 2007
Posts: 9,486
Likes: 67
From: Melbourne, Australia
ok so the theory is that under some conditions (ie old oil maybe) the mivec cams can't keep up.
particularly the exhaust cam since during spool it changes quite a lot.. and if its lagging behind means that the exhaust cam will be retarded too much on peak boost (for a short period of time)
P0011 and P0014 are meant to pop when the cams are out of range from their target, BUT it requires 5 seconds detection period... much longer than is useful.
its only a theory, but does make sense..
particularly the exhaust cam since during spool it changes quite a lot.. and if its lagging behind means that the exhaust cam will be retarded too much on peak boost (for a short period of time)
P0011 and P0014 are meant to pop when the cams are out of range from their target, BUT it requires 5 seconds detection period... much longer than is useful.
its only a theory, but does make sense..
Did a lot of testing today, the actual was around 1-3 degrees slower than target when going wot but while crusing it was pretty much spot on.
This is great, thanx mrfred & tephra
This is great, thanx mrfred & tephra
Thread Starter
Joined: Feb 2007
Posts: 9,486
Likes: 67
From: Melbourne, Australia
yes - my initial WOT log, looks like the exhaust cam never reaches the target.
now this maybe because the target map is based off a different load to what I am logging, but that would be a bit strange.. because its out by about 40 load points...
now this maybe because the target map is based off a different load to what I am logging, but that would be a bit strange.. because its out by about 40 load points...
Thread Starter
Joined: Feb 2007
Posts: 9,486
Likes: 67
From: Melbourne, Australia
mrfred posted USDM memory addresses last page...
SiC posted the formula last page...
my formula above is a bit easier on the brain and a little bit more accurate
SiC posted the formula last page...
my formula above is a bit easier on the brain and a little bit more accurate
ok so the theory is that under some conditions (ie old oil maybe) the mivec cams can't keep up.
particularly the exhaust cam since during spool it changes quite a lot.. and if its lagging behind means that the exhaust cam will be retarded too much on peak boost (for a short period of time)
P0011 and P0014 are meant to pop when the cams are out of range from their target, BUT it requires 5 seconds detection period... much longer than is useful.
its only a theory, but does make sense..
particularly the exhaust cam since during spool it changes quite a lot.. and if its lagging behind means that the exhaust cam will be retarded too much on peak boost (for a short period of time)
P0011 and P0014 are meant to pop when the cams are out of range from their target, BUT it requires 5 seconds detection period... much longer than is useful.
its only a theory, but does make sense..
I.e. a 5w-30 eventually breaks down to a 5w-20. So running something like 0w-40 might be better?
Sorry, just saw this for the first time. Only read up to page two.
The cylinders you listed in order from left to right I am assuming. So the low compression is in #3 actually. The last two cars we took apart had damage/low compression on #3 and seems to be a pattern to that cylinder.
I'd change the fuel pump relay for sure.
How many miles are on the car now?
If you need something let me know.
The cylinders you listed in order from left to right I am assuming. So the low compression is in #3 actually. The last two cars we took apart had damage/low compression on #3 and seems to be a pattern to that cylinder.
I'd change the fuel pump relay for sure.
How many miles are on the car now?
If you need something let me know.








