Pointless NTEC chat thread
^^ if we want to play in real macro economics though, the free market does not set the price. Because the corn farmers are subsidized to grow corn, and actually in many cases, to NOT grow corn, impacting the price. And the massive tariff on imported ethanol (which brazil could sell us for cheap) has also caused a misappropriation of resources into ethanol production. I'm all for e85 because we can make lots of power with it - but without government interference, there is about a 0% chance we'd be working with it. A true free market would kill it, because gasoline is cheaper and easier to make right now.
lol Virtual dyno is a joke. I did a pull the day I got my car back from cobb just for fun. Cobb dyno read 393hp and the ap read 485hp and 400 lbs of torque. I used 3684 as my weight.
I have been asking Cobb guys for over a year to do a back to back run in VD with their official Cobb log. None yet have come to the call, well a few have but they usually whine that the results were lower than on the drums. A lot of the open source tuners have and it has consistently shown like results. Like is relative since no two real dyno's read so accurately anyhow. It isn't much of a simulation when it is simple arithmetic. How much does it weigh, how fast does it go, what is it's gear ratio...
All you have to do is calculate the revs/hr and find the revs/min and then pass that through...
Horsepower = Torque x RPM/5252
And you can plot both torque and horsepower, even in Excel. My point was I don't get why the AP cannot get that simplistic math right. I think they should change the firmware to look at a log instead of trying to capture live data. There is a large margin for error asking the user to do anything.
I know I use VD and my mods and tune rank right up there with what Cobb and others are cranking out. Albeit +/- 5% or so sometimes but then again we could be lame like the Subies and apply SAE corrections to get better results!
The only real variable is folks don't really know how much their cars actually weigh when trying to use the calculations.
All you have to do is calculate the revs/hr and find the revs/min and then pass that through...
Horsepower = Torque x RPM/5252
And you can plot both torque and horsepower, even in Excel. My point was I don't get why the AP cannot get that simplistic math right. I think they should change the firmware to look at a log instead of trying to capture live data. There is a large margin for error asking the user to do anything.
I know I use VD and my mods and tune rank right up there with what Cobb and others are cranking out. Albeit +/- 5% or so sometimes but then again we could be lame like the Subies and apply SAE corrections to get better results!

The only real variable is folks don't really know how much their cars actually weigh when trying to use the calculations.
Last edited by SiliconTek; Dec 11, 2011 at 05:46 PM.
I'm not trying to fan any flames but I know for a fact that a certain someones VD numbers on pump gas that claim to be higher that everyone's else's e85 numbers on a real dyno is just ludicrious.
I did a VD run on my Cobb AP and it showed 536 hp and 530 tq. When the real dynos show 414 and 375. Alex did the same and showed 484 hp and his real number was 393 hp. VD just isn't accurate compared to a real dyno. There are just too many variables. The biggest being people claiming thier cars weigh absurd weights.
Not to defray however...a dyno is just a tool. Nothing more. If its not calibrated right the results are meaningless.
I did a VD run on my Cobb AP and it showed 536 hp and 530 tq. When the real dynos show 414 and 375. Alex did the same and showed 484 hp and his real number was 393 hp. VD just isn't accurate compared to a real dyno. There are just too many variables. The biggest being people claiming thier cars weigh absurd weights.
Not to defray however...a dyno is just a tool. Nothing more. If its not calibrated right the results are meaningless.
I'm not trying to fan any flames but I know for a fact that a certain someones VD numbers on pump gas that claim to be higher that everyone's else's e85 numbers on a real dyno is just ludicrious.
I did a VD run on my Cobb AP and it showed 536 hp and 530 tq. When the real dynos show 414 and 375. Alex did the same and showed 484 hp and his real number was 393 hp. VD just isn't accurate compared to a real dyno. There are just too many variables. The biggest being people claiming thier cars weigh absurd weights.
Not to defray however...a dyno is just a tool. Nothing more. If its not calibrated right the results are meaningless.
I did a VD run on my Cobb AP and it showed 536 hp and 530 tq. When the real dynos show 414 and 375. Alex did the same and showed 484 hp and his real number was 393 hp. VD just isn't accurate compared to a real dyno. There are just too many variables. The biggest being people claiming thier cars weigh absurd weights.
Not to defray however...a dyno is just a tool. Nothing more. If its not calibrated right the results are meaningless.
Last edited by SiliconTek; Dec 11, 2011 at 09:04 PM.
For what it's worth here's a spreadsheet I put together a long time ago that calculates SAE whp and wtq from tach logs. You need to know stuff like gearing, tire size, weight, frontal area, drag coef and atmospheric conditions for it to work correctly.



